Pinsir Doesn't Evolve into Heracross!?!?

[DarkDoom3000]

That's not all Cloyster resembles

Yeah, I know... Can't unsee.

One thing i never got.

Thunder Stone -> Jolteon
Fire Stone -> Flareon
Water Stone -> Vaporeon

...
Why doesn't leafeon evolve with Leafstone. Instead of the supid evolve at place X nonsense.
Leaf Stone -> Leafeon
Speaking of which....
Moon Stone -> Umbreon
Sun Stone -> Espeon


Also, why does a Dusk and Dawn stone even exist? Why not use moon/sun stones. They're underused as it is.

 

[archeops14]

What I never got was sometimes there are hidden items in the trash. Why would you want to keep it? It's in the trash for a reason.

Speaking of which, why do they throw away perfectly good items that still work in the bin? It just doesn't make since.

 

[Nideous]

I was just running around on Victory Road in Fire Red and I met an Arbok. Here's what it did on the first turn:

Wild Arbok used Acid! It's super Effective!

Does anybody else see a problem with that? XD

Also, why is it that you can be tearing up the evil team's base, stop for a moment and run to the pokemon center, then go shopping for a few hours, and even head off and gamble for a while, and when you (finally) get back, nothing has changed. You'd think that if the evil team got a break like that they'd maybe take some defensive measures, like locking the doors or healing their faint pokemon.

 

[deoxys121]

Why is Poison only super-effective against Grass? I think it should also be super-effective against Fighting (even the strongest fighter will succumb to poison).

How on earth is Meloetta part Normal-type???? It doesn't make sense!

Darmanitan really should be Fire/Fighting.

Braviary should be Fighting/Flying, since it's based on a war eagle, and learns Superpower.

 

[johnny18]

Why isn't Samurott a water/fighting type?
It has a sword with it (If anyone has a pokedex 3D, you will see it).

 

[zlip]

The Champion takes back the title behind your back.

Why isn't cubone related to kanguskong? With out the mask it would look very similar to the baby its holds.

Poliwrath's B/W pokedex entry: "With its extremely tough muscles, it can keep swimming in the Pacific Ocean without resting."...

Ash: What the heck is a Pacific Ocean?!?!?

Y is goldduck blue and has a psychic jewel on its head while psyduck is gold?

Why does Samurott have the ssame designs onits arms as Swampert?

Blaziken had it fightning type stolen twice in a row now (infernape and emboar)

Parents dont mind you gone for days upon days and they know you have no shelter/food/etc

 

[Weavile05]

A pig is fire/fighting type.... really?
A pokemon whose name looks like Samurai isn't fighting type...
A Snake isn't part poison type
I get the whole fighting -> Dark to Fairr -> Dirty thing, but how does that explain Croagunk and Toxicroak...? And what about Scraggy/Scrafty? It's Fighting AND Dark Type!
How the heck did Lance get THREE Illegal Dragonites? One of those being seen before the Champion battle in the Rocket Hideout at level 40! Not to mention Falkner's level 9(GSC)/13(HGSS) Pidgeot, when it doesn't evolve until like, level 18.

 

[jammi567]

What I never got was sometimes there are hidden items in the trash. Why would you want to keep it? It's in the trash for a reason.

Surely a more purtinant question is why the main character would be searching in the trash in the first place?

Not to mention Falkner's level 9(GSC)/13(HGSS) Pidgeot, when it doesn't evolve until like, level 18.

You made a mistake - it's Pidgeotto he uses in his first battle, not Pidgeot.

Obviously, he went to Viridian Forest/Route 2 and caught one there - they can be found as low as Lvl 7: https://bulbapedia.bulbagarden.net/wiki/Kanto_Route_2

 

[deoxys121]

A Snake isn't part poison type

The Snivy line is based on non-venomous snakes, such as green tree snakes and pythons.

 

[Pyrax]

Why does Samurott have the ssame designs onits arms as Swampert?

Spoiler:

They're not the same. Swampert has orange ridges while Samurott has larger white ridges, one of which it keeps its sword in.

A pig is fire/fighting type.... really?

That's 'cos Emboar is based on Zhu Bajie.

 

[SuperStone]

Somebody might have asked it, but still:

How can "Recover" be a normal-type move, when "Rest" is psychic? I mean, recover just magically recovers HP, while rest is just sleeping.

 

[quilzel]

I have many wrong things
Why dark is weak to fighting? * How do you fight darkness? (Or in japanese "Evil". How do you fight pure evil?
Why Dark is weak to bug? *Bugs can see through dark and dark shrouds bugs times 1 effective.(And how do bugs fight evil?)

Why does dark beat both Ghost and Psychic? I know Psychic needed weakening after Gen I but it just doesn't make sense to me, especially when you consider that in Japanese Psychic is the Light type (I think) and Dark is the Evil type, shouldn't Light defeat Evil? And I don't see how Ghost types should even be effected by the darkness.

I'm not sure if this is true or not, but I remember reading somewhere that Psychic type was supposed to represent the mind. Most people are afraid of the dark, and bugs, which is where the weakness come from.

What really doesn't make since to me, is why are steel and ground types resistant /immune to electricity. All of the minerals in the ground make great electrical conductors, steel is also a great conductor.

 

[gvgisdi]

One thing that's bothering me... Why the hell did they make a Pokémon that can be a lawn mower or a washing machine? :(

 

[Lockmaster24]

What really doesn't make since to me, is why are steel and ground types resistant /immune to electricity. All of the minerals in the ground make great electrical conductors, steel is also a great conductor.

Ground makes some sense. Assume a bolt of lightning hits the ground. Does it stay charged? I don't believe so. I believe the dirt resists the electical current.

Also last I checked Steel doesn't resist Electric it is neutral.

What bothers me is why everyone is obsessed with Gyrados being Water/Flying. It's Water/Flying for a reason.

What I always wondered is why Ivysaur evolves to Venusaur at lv 32 yet Wartortle and Charmelon evolve at lv 36.

 

[Zadikal]

The gen 5 should be like this:

Emboar - Fire/Dark
Samurott Water/Fighting
Serperior Grass/Dragon
Wargle Fighting/Flying because his counterpart is Dark/Flying
Alomola must be Luvdiscs evo
Bouffalant must be Tauros evo
Audino must be another evochain of Happiny.

 

[jammi567]

One thing that's bothering me... Why the hell did they make a Pokémon that can be a lawn mower or a washing machine? :(

Because Rotom is Motor spelt backwards, and the formes that it can change into require a motor (and thus electricity, hense the typing) in order to work.