Hey Kyo Tsukino ! Well, I'd say the same thing is happening with me. I'm pretty much in mid of a conflict between boredom and excitement. I've almost completed every anime in my computer and now I'm looking forward for new ones.
But, it would've been nicer if you enlisted the genre you like the most !
But i can, suggest you some.
Clannad- This show will give you some heavy pearl drops. Yet season 1 fails to be such exciting. Season 2 which is "Clannad: After Story" truly lived to my expectations. Clannad might seem boring in the first gaze, or even till the end of the first season ;p but, I assure you my friend, season 2 is 1000x times better than the first season. It left me touched. It's a romantic, supernatural series which is heavily based on the emotions. I really cried like a toddler (even worse) after completing season 2. The pearl drops consisted both the gloom and happiness.
The story is about two high school students who fell in love with each another, became family, and went through tragedy. The story is just enough to make you shed tears of happiness and sadness. But the story isn't of sorrow at all, instead, happy ending is transpired in the epilogue or simply, in the ending.
Season 1 is pretty boring and mostly consists of Character Development, I'd suggest you to go through the pain of boredom or (excitement, based upon your taste) and feel season 1 to feel the real "feel" of season 2. Without watching season 1, I'd say it won't leave you so influenced.
Steins; Gate - One of my favorite anime ever ! It left me touched for day, made me a quantum physics freak! and made my life. Even though so, I wouldn't recommend this if you're not heavily into science fiction, or if you're not into so heavy stuffs. But this series contains everything, from action to romance. This series is still my favorite and am looking forward to re-watch it again in a next few years !
Tells the story of a self proclaimed mad scientists, and how he discovers TIME TRAVELLING , But much to our emotional demise, our protagonist finds some heavy secrets of time travelling and the consequences full of grief due to the alternation of time. The series, is so far, for me, the best ever produced.
One Punch Man - This is a hilarious humorous comical anime which shows the over ascending, over evaporating powerful aura of our protagonist SAITAMA! Saitama was a common man living in his own world in general, until the day when he became inspired to be the strongest in the world. He practiced every day and night, shed tears of blood and finally transformed into a being holding the power of universal demolition (We cannot say that, because according to the author, Saitama, yet is to be serious.) His amazing power leaves you speechless.
The action scenes, in my gaze is best the Japanese industry ever produced ! The action scenes will give you goosebumps !
The anime might seem like very boring for it's cover, but never judge an anime based upon it's cover my friend ! The anime is going viral all over the media. You can search it in google if you don't believe me.