Red(阿嘉島) vs. Ash(聡)

[Lord_Storm]

Red hands down, because he never lost to Bruno, but had to be frozen, while he couldnt fight back, and that was the elite four

Storm

 

[Zippie]

Ash actually lives in a coma induced world, so if Red actually exists in the Anime, Ash MIGHT win because the world is just a giant fantasy to him.

In reality, Red will win.

 

[GlitchCity]

Red will completely whip ash's little behind

 

[zeremonio]

ash maybe giving red hard time but in the end red will win

 

[Obsessed Gamer]

Red will definitely win. Maybe end up in a close match, but maybe. Red's strategy is a lot more effective and a lot smarter than Ash. They can meet each other if the requirements are met.

 

[Spikey-Eared Pichu]

No contest. Red would win. Actually, all the manga characters could whoop their anime counterparts' butts!

 

[Lemubaby]

Red would mop the floor with Ash's butt.
No questions.

 

[PhoenixChild]

Yeeeah Red would totally win this. I mean he fully evolved his pokemon, and he has the best fighting stratigies. Better than Ash's. Ash is just a failure imo. He's no legend like Red is.

 

[System!]

Ash's Deus ex Pikachu will almost beat Red, but I know Red will emerge the victor.

 

[Opposite Day]

Pikachu or not, I have full confidence in Red's abilities as a trainer. How Ash can possibly win is beyond me..

 

[The Bringer!]

Red would most definately win, but I'm sure Ash would put up a good fight what with his abilities to ignore logic and all =/

AIM FOR THE HORN!

 

[GlitchCity]

lol no competition there, red would kick his ass

 

[Ninetales433]

Red,since he was (or is) champion.I say he can beat Ash.

 

[The Apprentice™]

Red would win no doubt about it. Even if Ash had is best Pokemon he would still lose. Red is overall better. It's not an opinion. It's fact. ^^