first of all welcome !
second of all i think the club leader is going to say Weavile is taken..
but i think we should allow more than one of each pokémon as partners, or else the number of members in this club would be badly limited, and people would eventually have to go with a pokémon they might not like.
third of all ;
i can't really see Noctowl as a DARKtype honestly.. it IS nocturnal, but it's got more the psychic feel to me. it just doesn't feel dark.
Mawile would make a GREAT DARKtype. it fits so perfectly, also with its design, they shouldve made it a STEEL/DARKtype.
as stated before i think Glalie would be a mighty fine DARKtype too..
and Lucario.. actually, i do think that'd fit! again with the design.. yup! FIGHTING/DARKtype it is. XD;
i liked the topic of would-be DARKtypes honestly..
um..
i don't mean to spoil the fun here, but if this is about the pokémon in the actual games.. there's real stats for that..
the best ATK would be Tyranitar, and the best SPD would be Weavile ithink.. iono about DEF tho.
best SP.ATK.. i guess Darkrai ?
.. unless you didn't mean it like that?