4th Gen So, HeartGold, SoulSilver… whatcha getting?

[PsychoJigglypuff]

I'll probably get Soul Silver, because it was the first game I played, and Lugia is totally freaking awesome! But, I have been considering importing Heart Gold for a Christmas present. :D

 

[キラキラ]

I will be pre-ordering both in Japanese, it is my native language so it is better for me.
The only thing is the cost to ship to America.. =/

But the figurines will be nice.

 

[Aero Shock]

Personally, I would purchase a SS. The name is much more better. "Heart Gold" sounds girlish. IMO

 

[deathrider24]

I'm probably going to get Heart Gold but if there is an exclusive that I want then I will get the game with the better exclusives.

 

[11wildy]

I'm getting HG, because I have a way to get Lugia, but I don't have any way to get Ho-oh. I always liked the gold sprites better, because they looked like the Crystal ones. crystal was my first and favorite pokemon game.

 

[ca_michelbach]

I had Gold on the GBC and don't intend to change on the DS...Heart Gold FTW!

 

[Sweet Smoochum]

HeartGold first, then Soul Silver. Pokemon Gold was the first ever Pokemon game I've ever played/known about, and it got me into liking Pokemon again. Another reason why I chose Heart Gold is, well, have you seen the picture of Ho-oh flying through the air? It looks gorgeous! I'll get Soul Silver, too, but seeing as how more people are choosing Soul Silver, more people will be asking for Heart Gold exclusives on wifi. Hopefully, I can get both at the same time. ^_^ <3

 

[Starway]

Hmm well I lost my Platinum so I was going to get a used one but since these remakes are coming out I might as well see which one I'll get. I'm guessing Soul Silver since I like Lugia more than Ho-oh lol but i orginally only played Crystal but anyway might as well get Soul Silver (can't afford both).

 

[Firestorm94]

Heart Gold because Gold was my first Johto region game.

 

[Infernape]

Heart Gold. Gold was my johto game as well so I figured I'd keep up tradition =)

 

[Pokedude45]

well I already have pokemon gold and my brothers fav pokemon is ho-oh so we agreed Im getting soul silver and hes getting heart gold

 

[Magmarashi]

HeartGold ^_^
didn't Gold have better version exclusives?

 

[TeirusuFX]

Soul Silver

Just because Lugia is teh shiz.​

 

[Silverfan15]

I going to get Soul Silver b/c Silver was the first Pokemon Game i got and ever played. i have loved Pokemon ever sense i got Silver. Also i though Luigi was cooler then Ho Oh when i was young so that why i like it as well

 

[PokeMangaObsessed]

Probably SoulSilver.
I haven't played the original Gold or Silver, but I've read that Silver was better.
Plus, SoulSilver has a better name, imo. :/

 

[Stale]

Soul Silver first, since I got Silver first from the 2nd gen. games xd... but I'll end up getting both eventually. Probably after I beat the E4 on Soul Silver.

 

[Ecks-Dee]

I think i'm getting Heart Gold and my brother is getting Soul Silver. I don't actually know why though because i prefer Lugia XD

I think it's because we are going to keep it the old way. I had Gold and he had Silver, so we're going to keep it traditional :) And anyway, we can trade legendaries and they will get more experience with different trainers!

 

[Ray Maverick]

Soul Silver rocks and thats which i'm going to get!

 

[Foxnordic]

I played my brothers silver version but I'll be getting Heart Gold. I wanna be able to catch the pokemon that i couldn't in silver version -cough cough- growlithe and spinarak. And my brother will be getting soul silver :).

 

[Draco flame]

I'll be buying HeartGold, because pokemon gold was the first ever video game that was mine to call my own :O

PS. Lv 70 Lugia :D