So which is better... PMD or Pkmn Ranger?

[Icetricity]

Played both, but I like Pokemon mystery dungeon more...mainly because you get to play as a pokemon.

 

[Captain Hobo.]

I like pokemon mystery dungeon the best but I like both.

 

[Taemin]

I played both, and wasn't too impressed with Ranger at all, with MD I at least made it more than half way through the game.

Sooo I prefer Mystery Dungeon, even though I still haven't felt like playing all the way through the first game.

 

[Relith]

Pokemon Ranger ended so fast, and I could barely get Charizard and I kept swearing at the game, and then I put in PMD and had some fun!

 

[The Red Chain]

Unfortunately Pokemon Ranger is only fun to me for a little while..
The storyline is stale.. the main thing that kept me playing was the adrenaline rush during capture scenes.. nothing else.

Mystery Dungeon 2 kept me hooked with it's incredible storyline. <3
I played constantly just to find out what would happen next.
The dungeons got repetitive and annoying after a while.. but the storyline kept me playing and held my interest.

The answer is obvious.. PMD vote here. :3
​

 

[Anxiety.]

PMD. I don't really like the Ranger games all that much, I loose interest in them.

Also, considering the main game you play as a human, I'd rather play as a Pokemon for a change.

 

[Sasuke.]

Ranger IMO. Mystery Dungeon has to many complexes.

 

[whibrimul]

I accept with information:In Ranger, you just circle Pokemon a couple of times then release them. That's nothing compared to understanding what other Pokemon think and how they interact.

 

[Idiot!]

Insert random filler here.

 

[Pachireecko]

To be honest, I prefer Mystery Dungeon.

 

[Katie_Q]

PMD, I like playing as a pokemon and doing missions. ranger didn't interest me much

 

[patch.]

They both suck. *shot*

PMD, as I've always found Ranger boring.

 

[Ninetales433]

They are both good,but PMD is better.

 

[hiplop]

mystery dungeon destroys ranger , ranger is stale and boring

 

[Mew~]

O.O Shadows of almia isnt short!! Maybe the first one is but the second one isnt, took me forever to complete!
Plus theres much more things to do after the game then pmd! You can battle rayquaza and go through the temple thingee after the game.
I like Ranger much more!
I dont like mystery dungeon that much because it gets too repeative in gameplay...
Btw a heads up for before who aint buying ranger 2 because they didnt like 1, ranger 2 is worth buying belive me!!

 

[Sarcastic Prince]

Both. I can't decide it.

The really exciting one is Pokemon Ranger, where you have to spin
the Touch Screen several times.

For Mystery Dungeon, it gives you pretty intense
heart beat especially when you're facing the Main Story Final Boss,
like Dialga.

But to be serious, I still can't decide which one is better of the 2.

 

[BHwolfgang]

I never did play Ranger, but never really appealed to me. I thought it was cute that you were a Pokemon for once, and not a human. :3

 

[cubonekid]

PMD - got bored of ranger once i finished it :(

 

[Halcyon]

I liked both but PMD is really an emotional game. XD

 

[Tox]

Mystery Dungeon. I think the plot is better and it's more addictive. Ranger is alright. The graphics are fairly good. It's annoying that you have to release everything you catch though. I give Mystery Dungeon 7/10 and Ranger 5.5/10. They still aren't anywhere near as good as the main games though.