4th Gen Starter Pokemon....

[magrathean]

I know that Cyndaquil and Totodile are easier to raise, however, Chikorita is cute, and I do love a challenge.

 

[ReyRey-Pyon]

In Soul Silver I'll be choosing Cyndaquil as my starter, Because Typhlosion is just awesome
In Heart Gold I'm choosing Chikorita though
I rarely use Grass starters anyways so yeah x3

 

[Air Pichu]

SoulSilver - Cyndaquil (go Typhlosion!)
HeartGold - I'll think about it

 

[MegaKirby]

Chikorita if trading from Platinum is allowed before you beat the E4/get the national dex, if not I'll go with Cyndaquil

 

[Fallujah]

I'm gonna pick Chikorita, just beacuse it's my favorite of the 3. Also, I have two friends getting HG/SS, and they said they're gonna pick Cyndaquil & Totodile (I spelled it correctly!), so I thought I might as well complete the circle.

 

[atre05]

I would probably go with Cindaquill, but....don't you think it is a little bit too soon to decide? I mean, there's nothing bad with thinking about a starter, but some people are already thinking about teams and stuff.

 

[Sakiko123]

With Marina in Crystal I went with Totodile as it not only matched her hair and eyes, but it was also the starter the Anime version of her chose. In Gold I had chosen Chikorita. Since we have a whole new female character, I may stick with Chikorita or switch it up and go for Cyndaquil for the first time ever. We'll see...

 

[cruzader019]

i would rather pick totodile..why?..
it can learn blizzrd later on the game..blizzrd against chikorita=bOom.
water type against fire type..cyndaquil got crashed in the waves duh!!

i've chosen toto as my partner for ten times..hehehe
what u think guyz?..

 

[Retro Bug]

Cyndaquil, because I don't like the other available fire types. And I love Cyndaquil, it's sooo cute ; <3

 

[.:C4:.]

Totodile for sure. I always choose Water-type and he was my favourite.

 

[Nudge]

I'm gonna choose Cyndaquil cuz i chose him back in my Gold version and he's probly my fave starter :]
And my sis said she's gonna choose Chikorita cuz thats who she chose in Silver lol
She hasn't played Pokemon since the Johto days and is so excited for HG/SS just like pretty much all us pokefans lol

 

[Who's That Pokemon?]

I've never actually played a Johto game but I'll get a Totodile.

 

[*WishMaker*]

Chikorita for HG
Cyndaquil for SS
Why? Typhlosion is my favorite fire type and idk why Chikorita 0.o

 

[bewbs]

It's going to be a Chikorita for me.

 

[MizuJosh]

Seeing as Totodile was my first starter in Silver, it will be Totodile again for SoulSilver. :)

I can't wait to get my hands on Kingdra again (not that I couldn't in Diamond).

 

[Samme!]

100% Cyndaquil in Heart Gold which will be my main game and Totodile in Soul Silver which will be my side game which i will use to get Groudon and the version exclusives.

 

[laizyboy]

IM GOING WITH CINDAQUIL BECAUSE TYPHLOSION ROCKS

 

[Man of Faith]

Heart Gold: Chikorita
Soul Silver: Totodile

I love Chikorita, but am a bit tired of using it, so it's going into my side game. I like Totodile and wish to use it more, so it's going into my main game.

I might switch Chikorita for Cyndaquil.

 

[Dunsparce]

Japanese HeartGold: Cyndaquil (While playing as a Boy)
Japanese SoulSilver: Chikorita (While playing as a Girl)

Yep, I made my descision almost as soon as the games were first announced.

 

[Nof56]

Cyndaquil, because Typhlosion is my Favorite pokemon of all time.Plus I chose him in silver....