I can't help but feel an argument is being made just for the sake of an argument, but maybe it's just me?
I'm almost 100% positive it's just you. arguing for the point of arguing is generally stupid, and I don't consider myself to be stupid. what made you come to this conclusion anyway? was I being to blunt..?
I've never really seen much of a problem with the 30 day revival limit.
I have. It's quite annoying to deal with in the majority of cases. (some places I see it being a hassle here are OC and OVP, from what I've seen)
I mean, the topic has to be inactive for a whole month before you can no longer post in it.
what's your point? I just joined yesterday. I've already seen a few threads past that limit in which I want to post, specifically responding to another user, but I can't because said threads are deemed not forum worthy because they've been in existence for too long without being posted in.
That means numerous members have looked at the thread, and passed it up in that time span. Sometimes, topics just loose steam.
or maybe the members who've passed up posting in the topic were just not interested in it? that's not to say somebody else won't come along and be interested in it.
Besides, when you recreate the thread, it gives every member a chance to repost their opinions, many of which might have changed in the span it was inactive.
what's stopping somebody who's already posted their opinion/two cents from posting again? I don't see the problem with starting your post with, "well now it's been some time.. my opinion's changed, etc...". please don't tell me you guys have a no more than one post in a thread rule?
I know I typically don't post twice in discussion threads, even if they change pace.
we don't all work on your ethics. but I find it hard to believe nobody has ever quoted one of your posts and you responded. I come on a forum to discuss things with people. not just drop in a thread, post, and never look back, that usually occurs in an *opinionative thread. (although this doesn't mean I don't question or wish for others to question my opinion, that adds to the fun)
here's mine as well; two cents.
As for my own board, New Users / Welcome, I'd say this is a horrible idea. I would hope you would all agree with me that there's no real use in welcoming a person past the span of a month. Chances are if they're gonna stick around, they're by no means at that point...
oh my god are people really that thick? of course you wouldn't revive a welcome thread, I hope people wouldn't be that thick. (but the world has shocked me before..)
If this rule were to change, board-specific accommodations would have to be made.
so be it.