The Starter Showdown, Round 1 - Battle of the 1st stage Waters

[Charmageddon]

I thought this would be fun. Of all the stages of all the starters of all the regions, which one is the most popular? The winner of this round will go through with the winners of the stage 1 Grass and Fire rounds. Ditto for the stage 2s and stage 3s. Understand? Right, lets get some voting on.

Will you choose...

Squirtle?

Totodile?

Mudkip?

Piplup?

Voting will close in a week.

 

[Tox]

1.

2.

3.

4.

Squirtle wins. :3 Mudkip is a close second though.

 

[loliwin]

Mudkip obviously wins.

I liek mudkipz

 

[Xebelleon]

Piplup.

The others can't get Smeargle.

 

[Mujahid]

piplup 4 life ...!!! ;)
noone comes near

 

[teng23]

oh man, this is an easy choice! piplup wins hands down! i mean first off, penguins are the coolest animals ever! and second, empoleon is seriously one of THE strongest pokemon i have ever used. check and mate, piplup wins.

 

[III Michael III]

Piplup wins because he is a penguin. And penguins are cool. Also, he evolves into Empoleon, who is one of my favourite Pokemon.

 

[Thunderwolf1989]

Mudkipz for the win!
filler----

 

[Hamilton]

Totodile just because i can't choose- they are all equally meh

 

[Sweet Visions]

Squirtle is my favorite because I have the fondest memories with him. I remember playing with him when I was a wee fellow, so yeah, 100%. Second place goes to Piplup.

 

[Bluerang1]

Mudkip or Piplup but Pilup is so smug and Mudkip sounds and looks soo cute so Mudkip FTW!

 

[Meta-Morph]

Totodile. It is a crocodile, it's blue, it's the first water starter I actually chose, and it's strong!

Of course, Mudkip and Piplup are cool too, but Totodile is the best of them all to me.

 

[Timbjerr]

It's almost a tie between Squirtle and Mudkip for me...Squirtle for the nostalgia of being my first starter in my first game and Mudkip for the cool meme and how absurdly strong and useful Swampert is in the Hoenn games.

 

[Christopher]

Mudkip is the best in my opinion all its evolutions are better too

 

[Kon~]

As much as Mudkipz are teh awesomes, I have to say Totodile here ^^;;

Toto is just... the best. He's one of my favourites, plus, he can deal out some attacks! I mean, Totodile has teeth! And claws! What can Mudkip do? Waggle his fins at you?

I rest my case for Mudkip VS Totodile.

 

[michele]

piplup - starts out so cute, and evolves into something so strong.

 

[560cool.]

R Mudkips ma feivorit wata starta ? Yahahaha, yaha . So I herd ya all liekz Mudkippz ? Why nut ? Hoennz starterz rox teh moszt !

I am not choosing the others because :

-Squirtle - tortoises aren't my favourite .
-Totodile - Mudkippz pwnzz yazz !
-Piplup - They already made a penguin Pokemon (Delibird)

 

[chaos11011]

Come on I thought you guys Liek Mudkips.Well I do atleast

 

[Mew~]

I hate mudkips they creep me out... :(
But i chose it anyway because everyone else likes mudkips and I like being on the winning side :D

 

[Corvino]

Going for Piplup. Very tempted by Squirtle, but Charmander will always be my first gen favourite, and penguins are cuter than turtles.

I hate mudkips they creep me out... :(
But i chose it anyway because everyone else likes mudkips and I like being on the winning side :D

You've got some mighty fine logic there... :P