{Tile/Palette Rating Thread}

[Tyrantrum]

Here's some old tiles I made a while ago(trees only)..

I love it. :3

The tree tiles are amazing. :3
A bit small, bit very unique.
Tiles: 10/10~

The palettes on the trees suit them perfectly as well.
The mountain palettes are pretty good, but resemble as Alistair's palettes.
But they are okay. Never cared for those palettes much.
Palettes: 9/10~

 

[8th Wonder™]

rate my tiles though

Palletes: 10/10
The trees' pallets aren't like the real Pokemon games', and they have good shading, I like them. Also the house wood is lovely, so is the big iron rock thing and the paths. Good job.
Tiles 8/10
I don't like the tree tiles, some of them are too...fat. The Gym, house and grass are OK.

 

[Tropical Sunlight]

Map name: not important

Please rate the palletes!

 

[cooley]

Map name: not important

Spoiler:

Please rate the palletes!

The palettes are okay, in my opinion, but they don't match up at all with the trees. It's too blended in, or the colors all look as one. I like the palettes of the grass and flowers, but the Tiles you'd have to fix.

Palettes:
9/10
Tiles:
6/10(mainly because of the tree and that building/structure needs shading)

 

[пзо]

Hello Thread!!

Map Name: MOUNTIDE TOWN
Base ROM: Fire Red
Comments: I know there is no town sign, however i added that and i have a updated map right open now!
And I changed the map, however this never made a difference to the pallet!
Mapshot:

 

[Chimchar 9]

Hello Thread!!

Map Name: MOUNTIDE TOWN
Base ROM: Fire Red
Comments: I know there is no town sign, however i added that and i have a updated map right open now!
And I changed the map, however this never made a difference to the pallet!
Mapshot:

palettes:
i love them accept the mountains + water, i don't think they go well together.
7/10

tiles:
there good but the rocks look horrible, i think you should insert new ones and even a new house.
8/10

 

[Disturbed]

My new rombase, in the resources...
I need opinions on it ^^

 

[Tyrantrum]

@Disturbed:

Tiles: 9/10 - {Good}, The tiles are fine, except for the trees on the right. They seem funky to me.
Palettes: 10/10 - {Excellent}, I've always loved soft palettes. :3

 

[/Circa]

I don't want the actual tiles rated, more the mixture and the palettes I made.
See attachment please.

 

[Tropical Sunlight]

I don't want the actual tiles rated, more the mixture and the palettes I made.
See attachment please.

Very, very nice. I wish you'd release a rombase but you probably won't.

So's here are the ratings:

Tiles 10/10: It cannot be better in can only be more perfect.

Palletes 9.8: The tiles are perfect, but I don't like the brown flowers. And the house wood seems too dark in my opinion..

 

[Banjora Marxvile]

I need an opinion on tiles so far. I know that the grass is pretty much ruined, so I'm gonna recolour that at some point... Anyway, these are the tiles in a map:

 

[Soul.]

Spoiler:

heres a mapshot form my first hack..
please rate the pallets and the map as well

 

[~Teh Panda~]

Map Name: Diego Town
Base ROM: Fire Red
Comments: A small farming town after you venture through Almat Cave, this town actually hosts Battle tournament #1, that is what the building to the right leads to ;)

 

[Zeikku™]

Spoiler:

heres a mapshot form my first hack..
please rate the pallets and the map as well

:O
Holy crap thats amazing, goes together well. However, use the little rocks and medium rock made for mountain tiles over the mountains. They look a little plain ;)

Map Name: Diego Town
Base ROM: Fire Red
Comments: A small farming town after you venture through Almat Cave, this town actually hosts Battle tournament #1, that is what the building to the right leads to ;)

Nice pallettes and great use of tiles but you have a block error adn a tile error :P
both on trees. barely noticable block error though.

 

[пзо]

Here

I hope they are good.

[/url]

 

[Griin.]

I hope they are good.

[/url]

If you look at the paletts of houses, pc, market you can see that they don't go with palettso of grass and trees. So make them litle bit darker :)

 

[~Teh Panda~]

Rate plz with actual rating system

 

[TB Pro]

Rate plz with actual rating system

Rating:
Tiles: 8/10
Palettes: 6/10

Comments: I really like the trees, they are amazing, and the palettes flow with them well. The only issue I have is the tiles and palettes of the mountains, they seem a little odd. The ground and wild grass pals are kinda...suckish. They don't mix very well at all.

Suggestions: Make the ground pals flow more with the trees and mountains, and make the grass the same pal as the trees, or close to the same.

 

[Disturbed]

I hope they are good.

[/url]

It really doesn't look good, especially the trees. Somehow you completely ruined them :(
Everything seems to clash together, and it sways from light to dark throughout the whole entire map. The things that were inserted look poorly inserted too.
Also, use you're own palettes, if you don't, give credit >_>
Tiles - 6/10
Palettes- 4/10


EDIT: Heres mine!
It's kinda unfinished, but I need to know how it looks so far :)

 

[~Teh Panda~]

@Disturbed:
Tiles: 9/10, loving the Alistair trees and paths
Pal's: 7/10, The beach pal is a lil weirdish. Overall though great job!

-------------------
Here is an update on the palettes and some new tile entries! The new tiles for Underground