{Tile/Palette Rating Thread}

[Zeffy]

The grass palette was really saturated, what about this:

Still, credit goes to TB Pro.

 

[Pokepal17]

The grass palette was really saturated, what about this:

Still, credit goes to TB Pro.

Hmm, it looks a lot nicer, but I would add some lighter tones in to make it better. 3

Tile - 10/10
Palette - 8/10.

 

[~Teh Panda~]

The new "Sea Of Dreams" tiles for Kanto! Please rate honestly :D
Base rom: Ruby

 

[Haku.]

The new "Sea Of Dreams" tiles for Kanto! Please rate honestly :D
Base rom: Ruby

Trees are nice and match the pallete of the ground. and also the flowers and small leafs i think, are nice. Except for the ledge and grass. The grass is too big for my opinion, i mean it's like a big flower which you will have difficulty to go through. The ledge doesn't fit the pallete of the ground. For the paths, it's nice.
I'll give a 7.5/10.

 

[TB Pro]

The new "Sea Of Dreams" tiles for Kanto! Please rate honestly :D
Base rom: Ruby

I'm usually quite fond of your tile/palette choices, but not here D: Main problem for me is the palettes. They look pretty good sure, but don't you think they are a *tad* overused? Also, the wild grass scares the hell out of me. It stands out too much for my taste.
Tilez 6.5/10
Palz 5/10

 

[Haku.]

Spoiler:

Credits
kyledove for original tiles
and i forgot who to credit for the house.. anyawys.
My comments is that i know the ground tiles is a bit weird but hey! this is my first try at making snow tiles.also, i plan to change the ground, so please rate honestly.
I already got a rating from deathwish and told me to use 5 shading colors for the trees which i'll do that as soon i get a rating from you guys.

 

[/Circa]

Spoiler:

Credits
kyledove for original tiles
and i forgot who to credit for the house.. anyawys.
My comments is that i know the ground tiles is a bit weird but hey! this is my first try at making snow tiles.also, i plan to change the ground, so please rate honestly.
I already got a rating from deathwish and told me to use 5 shading colors for the trees which i'll do that as soon i get a rating from you guys.

The trees are shading wrong, the grass tiles are way too light, the ground is too plain, and the snow doesn't look drawn on very well, it doesn't show much depth at all. The trees are also the same colour as the ground, might want to fix that up. Also, the blue post thing looks like it's supposed to be white on top and the hedges are too light.

Theres no depth shown in the tiles, it all looks like one big picture.

 

[Haku.]

The trees are shading wrong, the grass tiles are way too light, the ground is too plain, and the snow doesn't look drawn on very well, it doesn't show much depth at all. The trees are also the same colour as the ground, might want to fix that up. Also, the blue post thing looks like it's supposed to be white on top and the hedges are too light.

Theres no depth shown in the tiles, it all looks like one big picture.

Thanks, i would take that into serious consideration.
I'll post another one as soon as i edit it to my liking.

 

[NarutoActor]

I'm usually quite fond of your tile/palette choices, but not here D: Main problem for me is the palettes. They look pretty good sure, but don't you think they are a *tad* overused? Also, the wild grass scares the hell out of me. It stands out too much for my taste.
Tilez 6.5/10
Palz 5/10

I agree with Jesse on the platelets. But I do not agree with the grass. If I am not mistaken those are the grass tiles from Legend of zelda link of the past. (one of my favorite games) and I think you did a nice job of it blending in with everything else.
Pals 6/10
Tiles 8/10

 

[~Teh Panda~]

Updates:

DISREGARD the old Ruby tiles which are still in there! They will be changes

Spoiler:

 

[Zeffy]

First off, my ratings:

Tiles: 8.5/10
Palettes: 9/10

First off the tiles are ok. But I can't just give out a perfect ten can I? The old ruby tiles are still there, you said it yourself. I don't like the ground tile, it seems like its a moon or something.

Palettes, they are ok. But I noticed you only edited the tree palette slightly. And I also think that the grass palette is showing off.

 

[Laidjon*]

It's a Pokemon Academy, like in Pokemon Ranger. It's also the first building I have ever made.

It's private, so nobody has permission to use it.

Please rate it very detailled, as I know it must have mistakes :P

No rates so far... Please rate it, as I know that the balcony platform thingy is shaded wrong, but I don't know how to improve it.

 

[Tropical Sunlight]

No rates so far... Please rate it, as I know that the balcony platform thingy is shaded wrong, but I don't know how to improve it.

I can't give you any useful tips on shading but I know that the biggest building's roof extends too little.

 

[Pokepal17]

Updates:

DISREGARD the old Ruby tiles which are still in there! They will be changes

Spoiler:

The tiles are really nice and have one general style.
However, I'd think the overused palettes would looks better as here the grass is too bold and the tree palette looks a little weird, making the overall palette too green.

Tiles - 10/10
Palettes - 8/10

 

[~Teh Panda~]

The 'New Saffron City' Tileset, I have yet to insert Silph Co. but I plan too.

 

[Banjora Marxvile]

The 'New Saffron City' Tileset, I have yet to insert Silph Co. but I plan too.

I like the pallettes, but the shadows seem too... Well, thick to me. If it was darker grass instead, it would look better. The tiles are superb. Only issue is the window reflections, but that is due to the "X-Flip" thing in Advance Map, right? Oh, and the tree trunk, the left and right parts of the roots seem a little... Straight, but not too noticable. Well, I like these so much!

Tiles: 9
Pallettes: 9

 

[sab]

I hope this is better than my last sprite...
http://img189.imageshack.us/img189/4986/uploadm.png

 

[kingfisher309]

Well, my good pal Deathwish made me this ROM base, he made it specifically to my liking and I LOVE it, just wanted to know what you guys think.

Map : My own (I made it)
Hack : For Pokemon Nirvana which is no longer in making.
Permissions : I have them all.
Credits for tiles and pallettes : Kyledove, peyi, Deathwish...

 

[~Teh Panda~]

Well, my good pal Deathwish made me this ROM base, he made it specifically to my liking and I LOVE it, just wanted to know what you guys think.

Map : My own (I made it)
Hack : For Pokemon Nirvana which is no longer in making.
Permissions : I have them all.
Credits for tiles and pallettes : Kyledove, peyi, Deathwish...

Not much a fan of the mountains and pallets of the thing. Also those trees seem a tad I dont know different from each other. The pallet also is a very IDK dull...

Tiles: 6/10
Pallets: 5/10

 

[TB Pro]

Okay, so I want to hear your thoughts about Mahogany's new forest tileset.

Stolen property is not acceptable.