2nd Gen "Well, wouldn't you like this EGG?"

[Sheep]

Do you remember what the Odd Egg you received from the Day Care Man in Crystal hatched to be?

 

[Zed01]

I don't remember it from my first playthrough from a long time ago but I guess it wasn't a shiny because I would have used it on my team if it was (and I do remember my team from that game).

I do however remember the Odd Eggs from my other two playthroughs of Crystal after the game came out on the Virtual Console. The first one was a shiny Cleffa and the second one was a non-shiny regular Elekid.

 

[Devalue]

Cannot say with certainty. Lost that save file to the sands of time. Guesses something unremarkable like Igglybuff or Cleffa. Was definitely not shiny.

 

[Bellsprout]

I just did a play through and it was pichu which I was so disappointed with. I was really hoping for smoochum or tyrogue.

 

[Fairy]

I'm sure I've gotten them all at one point or another. Played a lot of Crystal lol. Don't remember any shinies though.

 

[Venonat in Space]

I should restart my VC Crystal one day. In my current play-through of VC Crystal, I transferred everyone except a random Swinub (and maybe a few HM slaves, idk I have to check) to Home, and have 7 gym badges. So...one day, I will restart it. *shrug*

In other words, I honestly forgot what the egg gave me. I vaguely remember being very happy with what I got though, even though it was NOT shiny. The next time I replay VC Crystal, I will let you know what I got.

 

[ReKoil]

Igglybuff, Cleffa and Smoochum on the VC version.
Didn't see any of the others.

 

[icycatelf]

I haven't played Crystal many times, but I think my first was an Elekid. SR'd until I got a Shiny one.

Seems like it might've been Cleffa in another playthrough.

 

[giradialkia]

In my VC version, I got a Pichu. I love Raichu, but happiness-based evolutions (and stone evolutions) are a real pain in 2nd gen, so I wasn't too happy.
But since then, I've gotten hold of a Crystal cartridge, replaced the battery and got myself a shiny Elekid. Not the wildest variation of colours, but still happy with it!

 

[agravedigger]

shiny pichu, I think! I know I had a shiny raichu on my team.