3rd Gen Which Johto Starter would you pick in Emerald?

[yellowparrot]

Apparently, if you beat the Elite Four in Pokemon Emerald, and complete the Hoenn Pokemon, Professor Birch is supposed to call you and offer you to pick one of the Johto starters.:) I'm working towards this right now, but I need to know what other people think.
I wanted to pick the least popular one, so that I can trade for the others.

 

[Tashiro]

Cyndaquil would be my choice. I've loved quilava for ages.

 

[Underoos]

I'd go for Cyndaquil all the way. It's always been my favorite ever since I played Silver.

 

[True Reign]

I would definitely choose Totodile. I've always been a fan of the cheery, crocodile-like Pokemon. With Feraligatr's high attack, Dragon Claw could be a beast. :)

 

[PokemonMichael]

I chose Chikorita.
After many hours of game play i got a Meganium LVL 100
I still have it.

 

[Bibliophibian]

I always go with Cyndaquil, since it's my favorite starter out of any region.

 

[QANTAN]

If I recall correctly, you get it after you've captured 200 (Not 202) Hoenn Pokemon. You also get the National Dex as well as a Johto starter to get you on your way. I'd choose Totodile, he did a lot of great things back in the 2nd Gen.

 

[msdmario]

If I recall correctly, you get it after you've captured 200 (Not 202) Hoenn Pokemon. You also get the National Dex as well as a Johto starter to get you on your way. I'd choose Totodile, he did a lot of great things back in the 2nd Gen.

Wrong. You don't earn the National Dex when completing the Hoenn Dex. This is not D/P/Pt. You get the National Dex after beating the Elite Four for the first time.

As for choosing the starter, I would probably pick Totodile since I usually choose the water Pokemon in every generation. If you want a least popular Pokemon like you mentioned earlier, you should probably choose Chikorita. Grass starters are usually the least popular in every generation. Fire starters are extremely overated and everyone usually picks those. Water starters are probably in the middle in terms of popularity.

 

[Chatot]

I pretty much have to say Totodile because back in GSC days, I usually chose him, and one of my favorite Pokemon is it's evolution, Feraligatr.

 

[Dominus Temporis]

I've always thought Cyndaquil and his line were incredibly awesome, so that's who I'd pick.

Plus, their design is simple, yet cool and effective.

 

[Deeje]

Definately Cyndaquil. Only fire starter line to not get a secondary type, to stick true the the 'Fire' starter choice. He is also cute-cool looking and can end up with rad moves.

 

[Zelda]

Cyndaquil...isn't Quilava and Cyndaquil so cute? But not only that but because well I love fire types they're my second fav.

 

[Artemis]

I have to say Cyndaquil...fire is cool and cyndaquil i cute...while its evolution line rocks!

 

[DaPews]

The fire pokemon are always the best pick. Even though the water type gym leader is REALLY hard to beat with it...they look the coolest.

 

[wolf]

Totodile since I already got a Cyndaquil from Colosseum.

 

[.emerald]

For some reason, I picked Chikorita.

Maybe because of its ability to use Earthquake...
I wouldn't want Cyndaquil cause its soft. But it looks cool...

I had second thoughts though with Totodile.

 

[Asmo-deus]

Cyndaquil, i used a Quilava in the Lvl 50 Battle Factory, so yeah. I'm gonna pick with Cyndaquil.

 

[SoulRed12]

Probably Chikorita. I've already got good fire and water pokemon, I need a grass type.

 

[EnteiFirecracker]

Cyndaquil easily.
It's my favorite out of the Johto Starters.

 

[.:Kanto:.]

I'd pick Totodile for obvious reasons lol.
1. It's cute
2. It's a water type
3. whats more awsome than a crocodile based water type?!?