Which Pokémons would you like as starters?

[The Hero Without a Name]

I would pick Togepi, but it'd be hell trying to raise him (unless he got a special move like Tri Attack right off the bat).

 

[Heartless33]

I would like pickachu as a starter in D/P.

 

[The Bringer!]

I would like a game where the story alternated between three different characters, each of which being able to choose from a different triangle.
Poison>Grass>Ground
Fire>Steel>Rock
Fighting>Rock>Flying
The three different beginning areas could be a heavily wooded forest, an industrial city, and a small mountain town respectively.

 

[Aegis]

Lawl, I know this is the most cliche thing ever, but I think Eevee as a starter choice would be kind of cute :[ And then around the fourth gym or so you could do some side story to get the conditions of your choice to evolve it to whichever evolution of it you want. That'd be sweet, in my opinion >_>

 

[Thundєr]

I would pick Gastly or some other ghost-type pokemon.

 

[Jake♫]

The simple fact in the matter is (I know, ignorance XD) is that Nintendo is very unlikely to change the triangle cycle from Grass-Water-Fire. If I could choose I'd go Dark-Psychic-Fighting, but it won't happen :/

 

[Ryusheika]

If we were able to get away from the Fire, Grass, and Water starters, I'd like to go with Normal, Dark, and Electric. If that were the case, I'd use Munchlax, Shinx, and Sneasel.

 

[Gyroh]

The simple fact in the matter is (I know, ignorance XD) is that Nintendo is very unlikely to change the triangle cycle from Grass-Water-Fire. If I could choose I'd go Dark-Psychic-Fighting, but it won't happen :/

And the reason it wouldn't is because Dark is immune to Psychic. If psychic attacks were "not very effective" on dark Pokémons, then it would work. And the main reason is because the've done the grass water fire triangle in every generation and I don't think they'll ever change it.

 

[EffervescentEevee]

Eevee!!!

or three Eeveelutions:classic:

 

[Squeegee Beckenheim]

I don't think that the classic starters could ever be replaced, and I don't think that I could even consider anything else.