Everybody by The Backstreet Boys
When I first remember hearing this I thought the lyrics sounded kinda stupid, the way that some of the phrases were being growled for effect didn't impress me, and I was not instantly made a fan of this band. I realize now that I had taken the song more seriously than it was ever taking itself, and had a good time recently when I didn't just hear the song play somewhere like I had before, but actually saw the music video for it, and realized that they treated you a little tongue-in-cheek horror movie in the style of Michael Jackson's Thriller, and it made me bop my head to beat and laugh, and just go with the silly fun like you're supposed. So the song has grown on me, and so has BSB's music in general, when they're singing intimately in love ballads like All I Have to Give and Shape of My Heart, or in traditional Christmas Carols I can't help but admire their lush vocal harmonies. They remind me of Boyz II Men.