Hello people, I have a dilemma. I finally got enough candy to evolve a Magikarp. They're rarer than hen's teeth round these parts, so it's taken me this long to reach that magic 400. Now, the decision I have to make is whether to evolve my best Magikarp or my shiny Magikarp. I mean, I don't give a toss about gyms and battling so my need for as strong a Gyarados as possible is minimal, and a red Gyarados would be awesome to have. But at the same time, if you had a CP846 Pokémon and a CP117 of the same Pokémon, you'd evolve the higher one, right? The CP of my Magikarp isn't as big as that, though, I'm just making a point. {XD} One is CP144 and the shiny one is CP73.
I can't decide which one to evolve! I'm currently on 460 candy so it'll take me chuffing ages to get enough to evolve another one.