If Brock does leave fifth Generation: will you be happy?

[PearlShipper4Life]

I was sad when Misty left the series. I'll be even sadder if Brock leaves, as then only Ash will remain (they can't replace him, now can they...). What's with all the random switching anyway? Couldn't they just stick to the original trio? =/

Well, its not like the original group will ever return any ways.
If Brock leaves it will be brand new pretty much.
I heard spoilers of him having a dream of some sort, thus having people think he's going leave. Switching=Good some times. Imagine Ash with fifth Generation Boy and Girl, I think it'd be pretty cool. Course this is just my opinion. I hope they give the fifth Genration boy a lot of personality along with generation girl. Than, will have the rivals to worry about too. Than oldies characters returning still so it won't be so bad.

 

[Artic.uno]

I think it would be interesting if they had a different hero than Ash. Perhaps he could be a side character, or perhaps if some think Gen 5 is in the future, it could be an older Ash.

I would prefer if they kept Brock though. And introduce a better female sidekick. I don't really like May, Dawn, or Lyra in the anime.

 

[cerulean15]

I'd be a tad disappointed if Brock was to leave. I mean yes, I was very sad when Misty left, but I'm still waiting on her guest appearances so I'm sure I can do the same for him. Especially his new voice..it makes him sound older and wiser, yet I do miss the old one as well. It would be interesting to see that the new trainer in the new region would be a male instead though. Its getting kind of lame with it always being a girl and the boy we always see in the games hardly ever has an appearance except for like a 2 to 5 second clip in the beginning of a movie. So thats something for me to look forward too :)

 

[Elite Four Lucian]

I think they should keep him in, I mean I got used to Tracey but yaaaa, Brock needs to stay..

 

[Celest8]

I voted "maybe". I'm not saying that I want Brock to leave, because in all honesty, I don't, but who knows? Maybe if a more interesting male sidekick was introduced, the show would get a little of it's hype back. The only thing is, I'm so used to Brock pretty much being the comic relief, that it'll kinda annoy me if another character tried to convey that in the same manner.

 

[Katie_Q]

I want them all to leave. And the start fresh with a new trainer. Plenty of other animes make new seasons with different characters

 

[GlitchCity]

Brock is kinda getting old (literality). I wouldnt mind if Tracey came back for awhile though.

 

[ShadowElliot]

Brock has been in the anime since the beginning, except with the replacement with Tracey for Orange Islands.
If he leaves, then there will be no one to see getting pulled away when flirting with girls ~_~.

 

[PearlShipper4Life]

Brock has been in the anime since the beginning, except with the replacement with Tracey for Orange Islands.
If he leaves, then there will be no one to see getting pulled away when flirting with girls ~_~.

Some people would say that's a good thingXD

 

[Andyb4325]

they need to get of brock. they havent done anything for him since bonsley evolved. i say get rid of him and bring back may or misty and the gen5 boy character as the 3rd member. so then two people go for badges.

 

[lucariojon]

they need to get of brock. they havent done anything for him since bonsley evolved. i say get rid of him and bring back may or misty and the gen5 boy character as the 3rd member. so then two people go for badges.

That would be cool =D
I wonder if Brock's crogaunk will evolve maybe?
Personally, I would be happy. Hes been in almost every Anime episode =/

 

[trid]

i want may and misty to come back and have a love triangle over ash >:l

but, Brock's been there from the start. He's as important as Pikachu or Ash, so I wouldn't want him gone

 

[Lucy Lu]

Well I probably won't mind. If he needs to go, he needs to. But he has been there since the beginning and he is like the cook of the group. If he leaves, I wonder how Ash will be able to survive without his cooking. Maybe a new member that joins might have the same characteristics as Brock...I don't know.

It is time for him to go, I won't be sad about it. Yeah he was great and all, but it is time for him to move on.

 

[Chibi Buizel]

About time. He was fun having around for a while, but now it feels like he's just a comedy relief character now. No role in the plot.

*FFF I accidently picked Yes in the poll*

 

[Andyb4325]

look at it this way he'll have apperances like may and misty did. i would like to see misty back more than may. and i would really to see the male from gen5 to complete the group because its always been the girl. plus misty was funny

 

[Darthbane2007]

If brock wants to continue his dream and he feels that he needs to leave the group, then let him..

 

[loliwin]

I wont be happy if Brock left, he basically had my taste of girls. :3

 

[PearlShipper4Life]

Well I probably won't mind. If he needs to go, he needs to. But he has been there since the beginning and he is like the cook of the group. If he leaves, I wonder how Ash will be able to survive without his cooking. Maybe a new member that joins might have the same characteristics as Brock...I don't know.

It is time for him to go, I won't be sad about it. Yeah he was great and all, but it is time for him to move on.

Well Ash would have to gain character developement.
Brock could teach Ash how to make food and learn.
Ash is going to have to learn this some time.
Can't always depend on other people to do things for him.
Maybe next Generation he can be the mentor to the other kids.

 

[Guy]

That would be cool =D
I wonder if Brock's crogaunk will evolve maybe?
Personally, I would be happy. Hes been in almost every Anime episode =/

Brock's Croagunk has a rash disliking to its evolution. It is seen when Team Galactic's Commander, Saturn and his Toxicroak is around. So, I really don't see Brock's Croagunk going for the next stage. Possibly Happiny could evolve, but this time around Brock doesn't really have a formative team like before. He's really been ignored these past few seasons. If he were to leave, then it'll be sad, but if I'm honest, it'll probably be for the best. As long as someone more involved in the anime takes his place, then that's all that matters.

I was thinking though; what if Brock's new interest is as a Pokémon Center Doctor of the sorts in which he accompanies a Nurse Joy for help. With Happiny, it could work, but that's just a thought. Then, if Brock were to make his cameo appearance in the next arc, he could have a Chancey by then.

 

[Roy-Kun]

I don't really care if he leaves. I'm still annoyed that Ash is gonna stay. (Can't do anything about it but complain, heh.)

Edit: Rather call for a reboot of the Pokemon anime.