Map Rating/Review Thread

[~Cerberus~]

Map Name: Garnet Town

Map Game:

Comments: I made this pretty quickly, it's for my hack Pokemon Sandstorm: Mewtwo's Front. View the thread when you can. Anyway, rate away!

Mapshot:

 

[sab]

I made this map just now and I would like to see if my maps are any good.
game: fire red
map name: don't know
comments: This is a starting town.

 

[Jordy San]

I made this map just now and I would like to see if my maps are any good.
game: fire red
map name: don't know
comments: This is a starting town.

I like the tileset, the tree placement is good.
But the lab realy screws the map up!
because of the lab i have to give it a 6.6/10

 

[sab]

I know what you mean. I just didn't feel like inserting a new building to fix that one problem.
Edit: now I do.

 

[sasquatchd00d]

Map Name: Upper Duglak Falls
ROM: Fire Red BPRE
Hack: Pokémon Enigma
Credits: Xiros - tiles, rhevarhe_duh - tiles, pey! - tiles, kyledove - tiles

Mapshot:

Spoiler:

Comments: I'm not really sure I like how this turned out but, I'd like it rated anyways. I'm aware that the same regular grass tile is used throughout the map. I didn't change those yet because I'm unsure whether or not I'll even use this map. The two caves connect each other but they can't be reached until later. The house there might be where you get the Old Rod. Not entirely sure yet.

 

[indepth]

This is my 5th and 6th map..

Time for me to post a map or two..
Map name:
Greenwich path
Map of:
Pokémon Fire Red
Comments:
This is the first route of my hack Pokemon Legend of Ryoshun.
Picture:

Map number two
Map name:
Mt Pluto
Map of:
Pokémon Fire Red
Comments:
This is the first cave of my hack Pokémon Legend of Ryoshun.
Picture:

 

[Gen200]

It seems I was passed over, last time...

Map Name: Note Town Outskirts

Map Game: Fire Red

Comments: The stating town/village/whatever two houses beside a town is... Neighborhood?

Mapshot:

 

[Nikkie.]

Rating

It seems I was passed over, last time...

Map Name: Note Town Outskirts

Map Game: Fire Red

Comments: The stating town/village/whatever two houses beside a town is... Neighborhood?

Mapshot:

Simple rating system.
You've got errors within the rows of the little trees. And the mountains look alittle odd. The flowers are over done, there's no path, how would the next map connect? For all that, you get a rating of 3/10

 

[Haz]

My map

My map called Opal Farm. The 1st paddock hold Doduo, the 2nd Slowpoke, a Slowbro and Seel and the last, a Machoke and Cubone. It's in the attached image.

 

[DarkShadow]

Map Name: twinleaf

Map Game: Fire Red

Comments: imk just redoing maps for sinnoh legacy

Mapshot:

 

[destinedjagold]

Map Name: Upper Duglak Falls
ROM: Fire Red BPRE
Hack: Pokémon Enigma
Credits: Xiros - tiles, rhevarhe_duh - tiles, pey! - tiles, kyledove - tiles

Mapshot:

Spoiler:

Comments: I'm not really sure I like how this turned out but, I'd like it rated anyways. I'm aware that the same regular grass tile is used throughout the map. I didn't change those yet because I'm unsure whether or not I'll even use this map. The two caves connect each other but they can't be reached until later. The house there might be where you get the Old Rod. Not entirely sure yet.

Comment: It's an awesome map.
Rating: 9/10
Suggestion: None...

Time for me to post a map or two..
Map name:
Greenwich path
Map of:
Pokémon Fire Red
Comments:
This is the first route of my hack Pokemon Legend of Ryoshun.
Picture:

Spoiler:

Map number two
Map name:
Mt Pluto
Map of:
Pokémon Fire Red
Comments:
This is the first cave of my hack Pokémon Legend of Ryoshun.
Picture:

Spoiler:

Map 1...
Comment: Needs more work. It doesn't look appealing enough, though...
Rating: 5/10
Suggestion: Try and look at the map tutorials. It is very helpful for mappers.

Map 2...
Comment: Too plain... It's too simple...
Rating: 4/10
Suggestion: Try and add some mazes to it.

It seems I was passed over, last time...

Map Name: Note Town Outskirts

Map Game: Fire Red

Comments: The stating town/village/whatever two houses beside a town is... Neighborhood?

Mapshot:

Spoiler:

Comment: Too simple and it really feels empty...
Rating: 3/10
Suggestion: Try and read some mapping tutorials. It is really a helpful tutorial for mappers.

Map Name: twinleaf

Map Game: Fire Red

Comments: imk just redoing maps for sinnoh legacy

Mapshot:

Spoiler:

Comment: The tiles are good but the map is too plain and it doesn't look good. The map looks like a scratch...
Rating: 3/10
Suggestion: Try and think of what you'll map first and then add in your creativity. Also, read some mapping tutorials. It's a very useful tutorial...

 

[Alice]

My first map didn't get rated, but I'm not surprised... it wasn't very good. So here's another much much better town I've made.

Spoiler:

Not part of a hack since I screwed up on the edges (probably) but I like the map, and I might remake it later to actually use. (If I ever do a hack.)

Ok, so now that everyone else has had their map rated, maybe someone could do mine?

 

[Haz]

I sort of got skipped over so could someone rate it please?

 

[Oddishinator151]

My first map didn't get rated, but I'm not surprised... it wasn't very good. So here's another much much better town I've made.

Not part of a hack since I screwed up on the edges (probably) but I like the map, and I might remake it later to actually use. (If I ever do a hack.)

YAO. THIS MAP IS TWO EMPTY. IT NEEDZ MOAR TREEZ. PLZ ADD MOAR TREEZ.

Really, it's way too empty. The paths are way too uniform. Mix it up. The same regular grass tile is used throughout the entire map. You have five different tiles. USE THEM.

4/10

 

[destinedjagold]

My first map didn't get rated, but I'm not surprised... it wasn't very good. So here's another much much better town I've made.

Spoiler:

Not part of a hack since I screwed up on the edges (probably) but I like the map, and I might remake it later to actually use. (If I ever do a hack.)

COMMENT: It's too empty for a town. It's quite good for a route, but not appealing to be a town. Add some grass on that map and it'll be a nice route. But even so, the trees and bushes, as well as the flowers are a bit annoying to look at, for maybe they're too scattered around the map?
RATING: Since it's a town... 2/10
SUGGESTION: Read some mapping tutorials and look at other town maps from great mappers like Neti.

I sort of got skipped over so could someone rate it please?

Spoiler:

COMMENT: Is it a town, or a route? Hm... I doubt it's a town, seeing as it only has one building there...
RATING: 5/10
REASON: You have used some of the tiles wrong. It may be a good map, but wrong usage of tiles ruin even the most appealing map.
SUGGESTION: Look at the tiles and understand their use carefully. Also, reading map tutorials won't hurt, right? It may also add to your creativeness.

 

[Haz]

COMMENT: Is it a town, or a route? Hm... I doubt it's a town, seeing as it only has one building there...
RATING: 5/10
REASON: You have used some of the tiles wrong. It may be a good map, but wrong usage of tiles ruin even the most appealing map.
SUGGESTION: Look at the tiles and understand their use carefully. Also, reading map tutorials won't hurt, right? It may also add to your creativeness.

Well it was originally a Farm. Tha't why there a great big paddocks there.

 

[Amaz!ng]

Map Name: Route ?
Map Game: RPG Maker XP
Comments: I've made a map, a big map and I spent a lot of time into it. Hope you like it, because in another forum, it was criticized.



In a link, because it is a huge map.

 

[Disturbed]

Amaz!ng

Rating: Nope... probably 6/10 (If it was made in A-Map... 9.5/10)
It's completely unfair that you posted this map. Sure it's beautiful, but it doesn't take much to map in RMXP. Now, instead of posting it here where it doesn't belong, take it to the Screenshots Showcase in the Game Making section.

Seriously, am I the only one here that read the front post? It sure seems like it now.

 

[Amaz!ng]

Oh, sorry, but I posted this, because maybe I'll use it for my hack. :/
Thanks for the hint.

 

[/Circa]

Amaz!ng

Rating: Nope... probably 6/10 (If it was made in A-Map... 9.5/10)
It's completely unfair that you posted this map. Sure it's beautiful, but it doesn't take much to map in RMXP. Now, instead of posting it here where it doesn't belong, take it to the Screenshots Showcase in the Game Making section.

Seriously, am I the only one here that read the front post? It sure seems like it now.

Sorry, but I didn't see anything saying you absolutely can't post maps from RMXP.

Map Name: Route ?
Map Game: RPG Maker XP
Comments: I've made a map, a big map and I spent a lot of time into it. Hope you like it, because in another forum, it was criticized.



In a link, because it is a huge map.

Very very professional map, not completely random so it looks nice but not too hard.
Considering how big the map is, if your going to put trainers and grass be sure to include ALOT of potions or healing items.
The only thing I find wierd is you put detail into areas of the map which cant actually be seen in game, such as the logs behind the mountain.

I'd give it a 9/10, mainly cause im not very fond of extremely large maps.