Map Rating/Review Thread

[simdu68]

map name: route 101

map game: Pokemon forgiveness(hack of ruby)

comments: this is the first route of the game, this map I got it in head since over a year(and yet other of course) and finaly when I started my second hack I put it in the game :D

(the tiles are already changed but I haven't got the update of the map, but no matter the changes are not that big......)

map name: Petalburg city (thats the original name, I must find a new one^^)

map game: pokemon forgiveness(hack of ruby)

comments: ........the last map I made for my hack so I want to know if I need to change it or leave it like this

 

[tinix]

Game: Fire red
Name: Garet town
comments: starting town for hack i`m working on

 

[Omega Zero]

Game: Fire red
Credits: Wesley Fg tiles

Spoiler:

Spoiler:

Spoiler:

 

[Mana1]

Mapname: -
Game: Fire red
Hack: -
Notes: Random map I did for fun, the idea is an event would occur in the top section.
Mapshot:

Spoiler:

 

[.LMG.]

For the first time in half a year, I found the inspiration to make another map. As usual, it isn't meant to be played in a real hack, so the areas that the player can't actually see are still meant to look good/ be rated. (Although it is still meant to be playable.)

Map Name: Crescent Lake

Map Game: Emerald

Comments: I'm gonna skip the story behind the map this time, so I can see what you think before hearing me point out the billions of obvious problems. (Although, most of them are just because it's near impossible to make a natural map with Emerald tiles.)

Just...very...natural. I personally like it a lot. 10/10

 

[Ray Maverick]

Mapname: -
Game: Fire red
Hack: -
Notes: Random map I did for fun, the idea is an event would occur in the top section.
Mapshot:

Spoiler:

I didn't know you were that good in mapping. This map's decent! Although, there is something I don't like. The wrong tree-tops. They just look weird, and I can tell you did that on purpose.
Anyway, look out for the border block, mappers screw b.b all the time.
I'll give you an 8/10. ;)

Wow! your map are amazing ^^ i like it a lot
10/10

Now my map...No name and is in FR:

Awesome, mate, awesome! Good job on that. ;)
The tiles you chose fit your mapping style which is good looking too.
But more trees in the middle of the map would be good.
A side note on the tiles: They look very good, and the pals are neat!
Rating: 8/10
I think you can do alot better; can't wait to see shooting star up!

 

[mitchel1]

:...:New mapshot:...:

[highlight]Map name[/highlight]: : Route 601 (remake!)
[highlight]ROM[/highlight]: : Pokemon dark cry: the legend of giratina
[highlight]Commants[/highlight]: yeah..what could I say xD I created a new tileset for DC like most of you people saw in the last update. It did took some time too to create this map, I beleve about 1 hour (damn tree overlaps (blocks) ^^"). I used for example the new tiles from alistar like the new lake, grass, tropical tree and stronk (with axe) ^^
I also used some tiles from Wesley FG like example the mountain, jumpstronk (or something like that xD) and ofcorse the HG/SS tree tile from kyledove.
Please rate the map and the tiles. I'm not really proud on the left corner above but thats my option.
NOTE: The empty spaces you see at the right of the map arn't mapped. This is because you wouldn't see in-game!
[highlight]Mapshot[/highlight]:
Click spoiler

Spoiler:

Thanks in advance ^^
----------------------
Mitchel1

 

[simdu68]

map name: route 101

map game: Pokemon forgiveness(hack of ruby)

comments: this is the first route of the game, this map I got it in head since over a year(and yet other of course) and finaly when I started my second hack I put it in the game :D

(the tiles are already changed but I haven't got the update of the map, but no matter the changes are not that big......)

map name: Petalburg city (thats the original name, I must find a new one^^)

map game: pokemon forgiveness(hack of ruby)

comments: ........the last map I made for my hack so I want to know if I need to change it or leave it like this

can plz someone coment or rate these maps? thx :)
I stoped hacking for aproximatively one month because of school -_-' but I still want to know you opinion and rating of these maps before I stop^^

 

[Muffin™]

Umm... Here's a map for my latest hack, Pokemon Crystal Clear.

Name: Unknown Island
Hack Name: Pokemon Crystal Clear
Well, here it is! (It's in the middle of the ocean, just to let you know!) o3o

WARNING: HUGE PICTURE

Spoiler:

 

[DuoRyan]

Umm... Here's a map for my latest hack, Pokemon Crystal Clear.

Name: Unknown Island
Hack Name: Pokemon Crystal Clear
Well, here it is! (It's in the middle of the ocean, just to let you know!) o3o

WARNING: HUGE PICTURE

Spoiler:

It look good
just look plain add some um cave,building except if this is a stranded island
and the add some connection as well
rating 5\10

:...:New mapshot:...:

[highlight]Map name[/highlight]: : Route 601 (remake!)
[highlight]ROM[/highlight]: : Pokemon dark cry: the legend of giratina
[highlight]Commants[/highlight]: yeah..what could I say xD I created a new tileset for DC like most of you people saw in the last update. It did took some time too to create this map, I beleve about 1 hour (damn tree overlaps (blocks) ^^"). I used for example the new tiles from alistar like the new lake, grass, tropical tree and stronk (with axe) ^^
I also used some tiles from Wesley FG like example the mountain, jumpstronk (or something like that xD) and ofcorse the HG/SS tree tile from kyledove.
Please rate the map and the tiles. I'm not really proud on the left corner above but thats my option.
NOTE: The empty spaces you see at the right of the map arn't mapped. This is because you wouldn't see in-game!
[highlight]Mapshot[/highlight]:
Click spoiler

Spoiler:

Thanks in advance ^^
----------------------
Mitchel1

Ok this look so sexy as of now! Love the tree even the new water,grass and cave tile and wow it look fun to go through give it a 10\10 for sexyness lol

 

[Pokestick good times.]

I'm a little too lazy to rate now, but I'll post a map I made this morning instead :D

Name: You know I never name my maps.
Comments: Random, not for use in hacks. Playable tho. I tried a little crammed dungeon-feeling, let's see how it worked out. I also added a little nice effect... just for the lolz XP
Game: Fr
Map:

Spoiler:

 

[simdu68]

map name: route 101

map game: Pokemon forgiveness(hack of ruby)

comments: this is the first route of the game, this map I got it in head since over a year(and yet other of course) and finaly when I started my second hack I put it in the game :D

(the tiles are already changed but I haven't got the update of the map, but no matter the changes are not that big......)

map name: Petalburg city (thats the original name, I must find a new one^^)

map game: pokemon forgiveness(hack of ruby)

comments: ........the last map I made for my hack so I want to know if I need to change it or leave it like this

I posted it 2 days ago and yet haven't got any answer, thanx -_-'

 

[BlitŻ1]

I posted it 2 days ago and yet haven't got any answer, thanx -_-'

You don't need to bump if your map is still on the same page -__-

 

[.little monster]

I posted it 2 days ago and yet haven't got any answer, thanx -_-'

2nd Map:

The lack of paths, blocker water layout, and poor sign placement annoys me.

6/10

>:

Also, stop bumping it if it's on the same page. I shall never rate another thread of yours again as punishment. >:3

 

[Ty2]

MapName: Paronie City
Comments: I made this for my upcoming hack in progress Pokemon Ecru.
Hack Name: Pokemon Ecru
Game: FR

Map:

Spoiler:

 

[simdu68]

two other maps of my hack, I just want to know your rating because no one really rated them in my thread.......

map name: route 102

map game: pokemon forgiveness(hack of ruby)

comments: hmm.........

map name: dewford town (to be changed)

map game: pokemon forgiveness(hack of ruby)

comments: nope......

and this time plz comment, not like before with the 2 other........thx :)

 

[Ven]

There are a few tile errors on the top left, all on the small trees.

 

[Nero_Forever]

Map Name: Route 2

Map Game: FireRed

Hack Name: Ocean Blue

Comments: I have made several versions of this map, and I like this one the best, although I don't like the 'bridge' on the lower side of the route, I may change it. That bridge is where several trainers are located to battle. Also, surfing is not allowed due to the danger of the erroding cliff, and the player enters from the south of the map.

Credits to: Mew_Ryn, Forgotten Memory, Kyledove for the ROM base.

Mapshot: (Warning - Long Map)

Spoiler:

 

[Skara]

Map Name: Route 2

Map Game: FireRed

Hack Name: Ocean Blue

Comments: I have made several versions of this map, and I like this one the best, although I don't like the 'bridge' on the lower side of the route, I may change it. That bridge is where several trainers are located to battle. Also, surfing is not allowed due to the danger of the erroding cliff, and the player enters from the south of the map.

Credits to: Mew_Ryn, Forgotten Memory, Kyledove for the ROM base.

Mapshot: (Warning - Long Map)

Spoiler:

Its a nice map but the dark water edges are square....
88%

 

[Pokepal17]

Map name: Arctic Town
Game: Pokémon Infernal Legend
Credits: Nintendo, myself, Fangking Omega and Manipulation.
Comments: It's meant to be square and Fire Red style, so don't comment on that. This is the where the final gym in Infernal Legend is located.
Map:

Spoiler: