Map Rating/Review Thread

[Ooka]

I was going to add some stuff eventually anyways.

 

[palkey1]

you can see my first map on my youtube videos section

please look at it

 

[LastHand]

Map Name: Route 1001
Map Game: Fire Red

Comments: Its my first attempt at route hacking and i want you all to tear it apart.the first house is the home of a gardener. And the second place is the future home of a family. Sorta under construction thing.

 

[palkey1]

looks good very unique add more flowers yay flowers

 

[suoert]

Map Name: Route 1001
Map Game: Fire Red

Comments: Its my first attempt at route hacking and i want you all to tear it apart.the first house is the home of a gardener. And the second place is the future home of a family. Sorta under construction thing.

i would give it a 6/10 because there is just way to much grass and there are to much flowers in one area.

 

[palkey1]

i would give it a 6/10 because there is just way to much grass and there are to much flowers in one area.

yeah thats true and at points is too cramped but does the lake have any reason or is it just full of magikcarps

 

[~Paul.Addicted~]

Well i am a beginning mapper, these are my maps:

 

[Typhmaster]

Nice map Paul 9.5/10 i like the tiles but the water is a bit 'random'

 

[destinedjagold]

well, it's nice... 7/10...

 

[cooley]

Map Name: LADEL PATH

Map Game: LeafGreen

Comments: -none-

Screenshot:

Additional Information: I changed the palette(Using APE), and will add different tree tiles.

 

[destinedjagold]

a quiet little town(a town with two buildings only? o_O well, okay...)
the tiles are nice. ^^

7/10

 

[cooley]

a quiet little town(a town with two buildings only? o_O well, okay...)
the tiles are nice. ^^

7/10

It isn't a Town, it is sorta like a Path, where you cross to get to the
next town. :^) :)

Offtopic: EVERY SCRIPT I COMPILE, FREEZES THE GAME!

 

[johnlycett]

Map name:Greenwood town
Rom:pokemon ruby!
map:

Spoiler:

So what you guys think where can i improve??

 

[destinedjagold]

wow johnlycett! The map, tiles, and pallete seems to work together to create a perfect work of art! However, it seems kinda quiet... By adding more houses(with no doors) could make it a very wonderful one! But not too crowdy...

Anyways.., love it. 9/10.

 

[Darthatron]

Map Name: ROUTE 001

Map Game: FIRE RED

Comments: Palette is edited in case you couldn't tell. =D

Screenshot:

 

[destinedjagold]

The route map is great so far... oh well... 7/10

 

[johnlycett]

wow johnlycett! The map, tiles, and pallete seems to work together to create a perfect work of art! However, it seems kinda quiet... By adding more houses(with no doors) could make it a very wonderful one! But not too crowdy...

Anyways.., love it. 9/10.

Wow you really think ill take you advice in.
Thank you :P

 

[destinedjagold]

Adding 1 or 2 houses without any doors would be enough, though. ANyways, I really like your map. ;)

 

[Lady Berlitz]

Map name:Greenwood town
Rom:pokemon ruby!
map:

Spoiler:

So what you guys think where can i improve??

That's great! I don't see any faults. The only thing that bothers me is those tree stumps.

 

[LastHand]

Map Name: Route 1001
Map Game: Fire Red

Comments: Its my first attempt at route hacking and i want you all to tear it apart.the first house is the home of a gardener. And the second place is the future home of a family. Sorta under construction thing. Well, I fixed it up a bit and work on it here is the map.