Map Rating/Review Thread

[cooley]

Well, this is Azure Town, the 2nd or 3rd town in my hack and the town of the first Gym.

It's a map from hacking Emerald, as you can see by the graphics.

Well, the tall building is the lighthouse, which is required for beating the game(You get the HM Rock Smash at the top). The beach house is just a fish restaurant, with people(mostly sailors and fishermen) who sometimes give you items when you talk to them(One of which is the Old Rod). The houses are just random houses with generic people in them, some give you advice or items. The gym's type is electric, so that's something fresh from Nintendo's obsession of making the first gym Rock-type. This is my very first map, so it has its bugs in it...

http://img355.imageshack.us/img355/5914/azurecityla8.png

May I ask a Question, Is that Olivine City with a MAJOR redesign?
This Map is very good, it's like I would have never thought of it? you are very Talented too.:)

Could someone rate this map.
New Bark Town; (snowy)

Spoiler:

Oh My Gosh! This is AMAZING!! I love the palettes and the new Tiles, this is Far better then any NEW BARK TOWN redesign I've ever Seen. It is Very detailed.

 

[Zanacross]

Just wondering what you think of this map.

the poke mart can only be accesed after you beat elite 4the cave will hold something special
and the grass area will lead to another route but opens when you beat elite 4 and have 100 pokes.
a new legendry is there.

this is m fist map so please be gentle.

snowy new bark.

i give that like a 10/10

its imense.

 

[loganmaster123]

rate my map
by the way i can do better than this

If you jump over the ledge, how do you get out of the town?
Anyway I give this a 9/10.

Reason:
You can't have everything perfect.

Suggestions:
None

 

[Zanacross]

please rate my map.
soon

 

[♠εx]

Could someone rate my map.
It's a remake of Pallet town using Ruby.

Spoiler:

 

[Binary]

Could someone rate my map.
It's a remake of Pallet town using Ruby.

Spoiler:

Wow the map looks awesome
8/10
Reason-the tiles look awesome
Suggestion-The D/P tiles dont look that great with the ruby tile. But its ok

 

[♠εx]

================
Map Name: Mount Went.
-----------------------------
Rom: Pokemon Ruby
-----------------------------
Description: This is a map from my new hack, it's relatively large because I made it like that, :P.
If your wondering why the grass is there, it is because you get given a Master Ball to
catch your first Pokemon.
-----------------------------
Map:

================

 

[Dark_porygon]

Mm don't really like it.
6,5/10
reason: It's quite empty
Suggestion: You should try to add more trees and flowers and stuff like that. Or maybe some water?

Spoiler:

any rates?

 

[Yellow Magikoopa]

Mm don't really like it.
6,5/10
reason: It's quite empty
Suggestion: You should try to add more trees and flowers and stuff like that. Or maybe some water?

Spoiler:

any rates?

Pretty good. I really don't see anything wrong. 8/10.

 

[Alistair]

================
Map Name: Mount Went.
-----------------------------
Rom: Pokemon Ruby
-----------------------------
Description: This is a map from my new hack, it's relatively large because I made it like that, :P.
If your wondering why the grass is there, it is because you get given a Master Ball to
catch your first Pokemon.
-----------------------------
Map:

================

Rating: 6
Reason: The map is way too plain, the mountains are too square, and the R/S tiles clash horribly with the DP tiles.
Suggestion: Make the mountain more naturally shaped, try adding flowers, fences, and other things to it (as well as windows to houses) that fit, remove the grass, and replace the RS tiles with DP ones or vice versa.

 

[Zanacross]

Isnt anyone Gonna rate m map??

 

[Gerri Shin]

Just wondering what you think of this map.

the poke mart can only be accesed after you beat elite 4the cave will hold something special
and the grass area will lead to another route but opens when you beat elite 4 and have 100 pokes.
a new legendry is there.

this is m fist map so please be gentle.

snowy new bark.

i give that like a 10/10

its imense.

I'd give it a 7/10
It's not bad, but having the mart secluded isnt really the best idea, unless it was some special mart in which case I'd suggest that you do something to amke it look unlike the ordinary mart. I'm also guessing that it is a town flanked by three routes (going north, east, and west) If not I'd suggest filling in holes with trees. but on the whole not bad. :t380:

 

[destinedjagold]

Hi! Could someone rate my map, please. This map is one of the towns you'll be visiting in my next Beta... I want it to be rated. Thanks in advance.
This map is made out of scratch in a Ruby Version ROM (specifically, in my hack......)

Spoiler:

 

[Gerri Shin]

Hi! Could someone rate my map, please. This map is one of the towns you'll be visiting in my next Beta... I want it to be rated. Thanks in advance.
This map is made out of scratch in a Ruby Version ROM (specifically, in my hack......)

Spoiler:

I'll give it a 9/10
There was only 2 things that I found out of place.
1.) that grey building next to the PC seems out of place with the rest of the houses in the town.
2.) the grass tiles. they seem very busy and could be potentially stressful to the players eyes when playing.

other than that great job :t380:

 

[destinedjagold]

I'll give it a 9/10
There was only 2 things that I found out of place.
1.) that grey building next to the PC seems out of place with the rest of the houses in the town.
2.) the grass tiles. they seem very busy and could be potentially stressful to the players eyes when playing.

other than that great job :t380:

The grey building, I did that on purpose, and about the grass tiles, well, oh well...

Thanks for rating it! ^^

 

[cooley]

Map Name: Route 85

Map Game: FireRed

Comments: I edited Route 1. There are also more connections too. Give Cred to '♠EX' for Tiles and palettes.
I know there are tree Errors, but It was too confusing to keep on changing it.(There are two trees anyways).

Mapshot: Down below.↓
~cooley~

 

[Zanacross]

The house in the corner, how do you get in it?
But other then that i give it an 7.5/10

 

[fredlocks]

what's with the lonsome tree in the bottom corner?

 

[destinedjagold]

Map Name: Route 85

Map Game: FireRed

Comments: I edited Route 1. There are also more connections too. Give Cred to '♠EX' for Tiles and palettes.
I know there are tree Errors, but It was too confusing to keep on changing it.(There are two trees anyways).

Mapshot: Down below.↓
~cooley~

I kinda don't like the building located on the right...

But the map is very nice, indeed. Thee have my word...

7/10 ...

 

[cooley]

what's with the lonsome tree in the bottom corner?

So you can pass through.

The house in the corner, how do you get in it?
But other then that i give it an 7.5/10

Well it is higher than a 5.(lol)

I kinda don't like the building located on the right...

But the map is very nice, indeed. Thee have my word...

7/10 ...

Thanks, it was supposed to be removed.