Map Rating/Review Thread

[0m3GA ARS3NAL]

Ok, two new maps here, what do you people think?

Spoiler:

And Map #2

Spoiler:

Ratings and opinions please?
(are the images showing up? My comp sometimes wont show them to me, but can you see them, if not, please tell me)

 

[Austinia]

those desert maps look truely awesome, the ygive me a good preview of how my desert region will turn out since im using the same tiles^^

i did so many ice maps, theyre so normal to me now that i like desert once much more xD
i think ill continue mapping LoF now

edit: what do you think of my latest map:
Map Name: Shaqiu
Hack: Legend of Fenju
Game: FireRed
Mapshot:

Comments: First Village of Huoshi

and pls tell me, whicch palette would you prefer, the first one or this one:

Spoiler:

i think the sand iss better in the first one and the roofs, plants and mountains look better in the second one, so ill probably mix em up

I like the first palette better.

Ok, two new maps here, what do you people think?

Spoiler:

And Map #2

Spoiler:

Ratings and opinions please?

I'm not sure why, but no images are showing up for me.

 

[Neti]

i dont see the images either

 

[0m3GA ARS3NAL]

Spoiler:

[img=https://img168.imageshack.us/img168/1377/cephaloscityoc4.th.png]

Spoiler:

[img=https://img146.imageshack.us/img146/7386/routebu8.th.png]

Try these (I wasn't using Imageshack before, Try it now in these spoilers ^)

 

[.Iramet]

yea i knew that map wasnt very good i was just trying to get a map on here becuz ive been trying for a while to do it^_^
@blackrainbow:Everyone uses others tiles its not wrong^_^
At least my map is original.LOL

 

[BlackRainbow*]

oh yeah it is. You have to get permission to use it.
Sorry for spamming

 

[Luck]

Or else it would be considered thievery.

here is a map i made, its supposed to be a semi-tropical route.

Spoiler:

tell me if you don't see it.
and please use constructive criticism since this is the first completed map i've made in a while.
honestly, im a bit dissapointed in this map.

Edit: If anyone woders why the trees are like that, its because i just hate trees with patterns.
its not very natural to me.And also, i have changed the grass to be R/S/E like, leaving more space.

 

[Neti]

hey i love that map, it looks really nice!

 

[Luck]

hey i love that map, it looks really nice!

erm, thanks but could you tell me what is wrong and give a honest rating?

Anyways, i found another map, but i made this map more mountainous since a crater apparently landed into the center(erosion took care of the crater).
i made this map to be more mountainous, but i put trees because i just hate treeless areas.

Spoiler:

like before, please give a detailed description about what is wrong.
i really don't like this map much because it seems really crowded, but i do like the mountain tile placement.
And again, tell me if you don't see it.

Oh, and the barred door is just as useless as the white rock in mossdeep.
Just an easter egg.

 

[Makorin]

Hiya! i've got a map i've been working on here...
what do u people think 'bout it?

Map Name: Frotus Town
Hack: Legend of Hatichu
Game: FireRed
Mapshot:

 

[Tyrantrum]

Hiya! i've got a map i've been working on here...
what do u people think 'bout it?

Map Name: Frotus Town
Hack: Legend of Hatichu
Game: FireRed
Mapshot:

The shape looks good to me, but it's a tiny bit empty at the bottom, and that Rom Base is over used...8/10

 

[tImE]

Hi, I've been
working on a Desert Town
for some time now and I thought I ought to post it
and see what people thinks of it.

Map Name: Subaku Town
Hack: Pokemon Nature Force (Not posted on PC yet)
Game: Firered BPRE Sorry xP Ruby AXVE

 

[BlackRainbow*]

44tim44 i really like your map. it has a nice layout and really awesome tiles. maybe you should put some more trees in it?
8/10

 

[.Iramet]

44tim44 that is a really good map i wish i could do somthing like that i would give it a 9/10 only because nothing is ever perfect
@blackrainbow-thnks for telling me and ill just use the ones atr whack a hack cuz they already give you permission as long as you give the creator credit for the tiles

 

[Tyrantrum]

@44tim44: It's a good map, the tiles r excellent, just add a few more holes and rocks...8.5/10

 

[Luck]

Hi, I've been
working on a Desert Town
for some time now and I thought I ought to post it
and see what people thinks of it.

Map Name: Subaku Town
Hack: Pokemon Nature Force (Not posted on PC yet)
Game: Firered BPRE Sorry xP Ruby AXVE

Its okay but can be much better.
The town is too bunched up and gets too empty.
there are no rocks in the water, it seems really dull, the top of the mountain tiles seem weird,and the mountain placement just doesn't look that good.
there isn't much to expect from a desert town but it could still be better.
6.8/10 for emptiness.

Edit: I know no one ever reads the page before the last page, so i'll put my previous maps on here.

Spoiler:

Spoiler:

 

[Mr.Fury]

i really like your map, nice simple with great tiles. 9/10 ^_^

*edit* didnt feel like double posting, so ill post my map here.

Name: Sequil Village (iunno were it came from, just liked it)
ROM: Fire Red
Original: Pallet Town

Please rate and comment 1-10
And keep in mind this is my first succesful map i have made, just for fun.





Also i am possibly looking for a tutor/mentor for hacking. ^_^

 

[Netdot5]

On the map, the ends of the path are kinda not so good. Make sure you are using the right tiles that make it flow. You need to find the connecter for the vertical and horizontal paths. Right now, they are just clashing together.

 

[Austinia]

I have to say I am pretty happy with this city I just made... it took forever making the palettes and inserting the tiles but here it is!

Sitrua City

from my Pokemon hack (Oak's Murder)

 

[Tyrantrum]

I simply love the placement of everything, especially the trees! :D
Very good...9.5/10