- 13
- Posts
- 10
- Years
- Seen Jul 13, 2014
so, Umbr30n, is your vote for Lyn then.
To be fair, we don't actually know when the murder happened, so perhaps it's a bit rash to be blaming the primary witnesses when the death could've happened hours earlier... Bagu would be packing a strong Stone Edge attack which would have easily been enough to take down the bird, but where is the evidence? Surely there'd be leftover rocks or sharp cuts on the body or loud noises coming from the room, but we've been presented with none of the above. It's possible the scream was just an attempt to pin the blame on Bagu, or it could've been a reaction to his attack, or perhaps it was just a genuine shriek at finding a dead body. Regardless, Bagu is still seeming like the likely suspect to me so I'll keep my vote placed on him.
Haha, I'm excited that the mystery isn't so open-and-shut!
AlexOzzyCake has a point - we don't know when it happened. If we assume it took place during the darkness, that means the murder was commited in just three seconds. In that case, I don't think Umbr30n's scenario would fit. Also, if death was due to multiple bites from Lyn, then I'd think the police would notice blood around her mouth. Three seconds isn't enough time to kill and clean off for sure. I'm willing to bet that the murder took place beforehand, and Pidgeotto was only put on display during the three-second blackout. Lyn and Bagu just happened to be in the wrong place at the wrong time.
Now, according to the type chart, Flying-Types aren't weak to either Bug or Fighting. Normal Types are weak to Fighting-Type, but the Flying Type nullifies it. Flying Types are weak to Electric... That means Lyn could have caused much more pain to Pidgeotto then Bagu, unless of course Bagu had a Rock-Type move hidden up his sleeve.
Now, lets look at the type chart again: Electric is resistant to Flying, Fighting Type is weak to Flying and Bug is also weak to Flying. If Bagu tried to kill Pidgeotto, Pidgeotto would have easily put up a fight and it would have easily escaped the scene. But Lyn... Pidgeotto would have trouble fighting it, because of the type chart, and Lyn would easily kill Pidgeotto with a strong Electric Type move.
Then, Lyn makes a scream and tries to pin it on Bagu. To me, it fits without any problems.
Besides, just because somebody screamed doesn't mean they didn't do the crime.
This is how the events most likely happened, from my gatherings of evidence...
The Pokémon decided to explore the mansion in groups, well, at least Bagu and Lyn anyway. What the others didn't know, was that Lyn had a fiendish plot to kill Pidgeotto, as they probably hated each other through and through... And eventually, Lyn was in luck, as she and Bagu managed to find Pidgeotto. Pidgeotto greeted the two firmly, and turned back to meet the others when Lyn started shocking Pidgeotto repeatedly, while Pidgeotto stopped for a second, and tried to run away. He was too weak, however, as Lyn was pulling him back with more of her electric abilities, as Bagu looked at the scene, frozen in horror. Then, as soon as Pidgeotto was dead, Lyn quickly made a note, placed it on Pidgeotto and gave a giant scream which caused everyone to arrive at the scene, which is where we are now. This is the reason Bagu's expression didn't change. He had witnessed Lyn kill Pidgeotto slowly.
Well, it's what I think anyway, and if Lyn does not get executed today, I bet I'm the person who would be killed in the next part of the story because Lyn doesn't want me to gather any more evidence against her. And if she does, we have more evidence to who would be the murderer, probably enough to give her away.
Wouldn't we all hear the electricity? Wouldn't we see flashes of light as dim as they may be?
I will vote sneazel for the above reasons that have been stated with him being much more agile and ninja-ish. If Bagu did not kill pidgeotto and if lyn killed him with electricty than why hasnt he dobbed him in because he obviously looked like he cared for said bird
Does the murderer change everytime or does the murderer stay the murderer until we catch him/her?