Pokemon XD VS Pokemon Colosseum

[Neo Android]

Which one was the best for you, i think Pokemon XD is the best cause of the expansive story, but the story is still the same which can be boring and ur visiting new and old places but, the old places have the feel of been there done that.

Dont get me wrong Pokemon XD i am really enjoing but now its gettng kinda boring.

Whats your opinions?

- Lone Eevee

 

[Synchronize]

The only real pro I think Colosseum has over XD is the fact that the main character looks cooler. The instant Umbreon and Espeon is also a plus, but that's prety much it. XD introduces a non-sharked Lugia into your GBA, more Shadow Moves, more Shadow Pokemon, better music, and a little more to do in your adventure.

 

[Deoxysguy]

XD is awesome, Colosseum was good but not AS good. I vote XD.

 

[Johto Boy]

If you played Colosseum first, like most people, XD got very boring. I loved Colosseum and played it like 3 times before I got bored of it. But XD was cheap in my opinion. It felt like playing Colosseum over again but with a few changes. The story wasn't as good, the characters weren't as good (or as cool). It did have some nice extra features, like the Pokespots. And the graphics did improve. But I got bored quickly playing through XD. I would give XD an 7.5 out of 10. I would give Colosseum an 9 out of 10. I just wish they would have put time in making XD more original, not just reusing Colosseum.

 

[Synchronize]

They really do need a GCN game with more of a likeness to Pokemon Stadium. I think we all agree that those were a little more fun.

 

[Neo Android]

yeah i agree, Although im the oppsite, i played colosseum first like everyone else and was very bored of the limited locations and the basic story plot, Although XD is very good in my opinion it still could of improved in the location and enhance the story, eventhough XD is still a good story, i have played XD twice now, and im about to play it a 3rd time ^^

 

[Entei Master]

Pokemon XD is much better than Pokemon Colosseum because XD has a better story line and many more places to go and do. The Pokemon on XD were really nice because the graphics and colours were just right.


My Rating for Pokemon XD: 10/10
My Rating for Pokemon Colosseum: 5/10

 

[Johto Boy]

They really do need a GCN game with more of a likeness to Pokemon Stadium. I think we all agree that those were a little more fun.

I liked the Colosseum/XD type games a lot more than the Stadium games. I thought the Stadium games were kinda boring. But if they do make another Colosseum/XD type game, I hope it turns out better than XD.

 

[Strawberry Delcatty]

For me, Pokemon Colloseum didn't leave as much to remember as XD. I haven't played both for a while (I did play a bit of XD a while ago for kicks), but I find myself liking XD more than I did Collosseum.

Another thing is that XD had two of my favorite (and obligatory for some of my caliber) Pokemon: MEOWTH AND DELCATTY! =3

 

[Synchronize]

I liked the Colosseum/XD type games a lot more than the Stadium games. I thought the Stadium games were kinda boring. But if they do make another Colosseum/XD type game, I hope it turns out better than XD.

Stadium is better IMO, because the gyms and E4 were actually a challenge <_<. Plus the mini games were a good way to waste time. And to add I could see myself play Silver on TV >_>

 

[PokeSmurf]

I liked XD much more than Colosseum. Infact, it took me several months to get through Colosseum because I was so bored. I beat XD in a few days.

Neither of them met up to my expectations though. I found that the regular GB games had the better story. I'll take a good plot over graphics any day.

 

[[Paper Wings]]

Though XD has a more extensive storyline as someone earlier mentioned, I prefer Colosseum myself. I loved the dark theme it had and the Hero's just too cute. In XD, though, it was the same, ol' "I'm the good guy with no father who's going to save the world!" shindig that's common in the rest of the games. I mean, in Colosseum, you can theoretically catch any Pok?mon you wanted, but the programming of the game itself prevented that. In XD, on the other hand, it clearly states that Michael's Snag Machine can only snag Shadow Pok?mon.

That and having to snag so many Shadows (four at once?!) just really irked me. Like Nintendo saw that the fans liked the Shadows and decided to milk that cash cow for all it's worth and then some.

 

[Hive Mind]

I rate Colosseum and Pokemon XD about the same.
I think it was a bit dissapointing when both of them came out. I've been really hoping for a new Pokemon Stadium type game.

 

[Chronos]

I'd say XD was better. I had a far better team in XD, and I enjoyed it more, as I didn't have someone following me all game. Although Jovi did scare me slightly...still, Dark Lugia was awesome, and the music improved.

 

[mewtwo-EX]

Looking at each game individually, Colosseum had a decient story, but was flawed in that it was too short with not enough pokemon to catch, and didn't feel like a GB game, as you had to search for save points. Also, some of the fainting animations for pokemon took too long (Vileplume, I'm looking at you).

XD improved on almost everything with an increased story, and a ton more pokemon. However, neither of them are the RPG that happens on handhelds. Nintendo made it this way, I believe, to keep the console and handheld version seperate. I would love it if they actually put a ton of time into one, and made it a full RPG similar to the GB/A versions. Maybe D/P will merge the two styles!

 

[Flame Claw]

XD has a better storyline, so XD.

 

[Dogboy2709]

well, Since Colosseum was nintendos first attempt at making a pok?mon game for the GC, that's why it turned out bad. but, since they now had more Experience with it they created XD but it's kinda hard for me to say because XD did not have a rotateable camera, but it did have a beter storyline, so i'm basically in the middle, or in other words, both of them get my vote

 

[PokeSmurf]

I agree with mewtwo-EX

Well said.

 

[Xygni]

I thought both of them were kind of weak compared to the handheld games

 

[Johto Boy]

I liked XD much more than Colosseum. Infact, it took me several months to get through Colosseum because I was so bored. I beat XD in a few days.

Neither of them met up to my expectations though. I found that the regular GB games had the better story. I'll take a good plot over graphics any day.

I am the COMPLETE opposite. I loved Colosseum and beat it in about a week. I played Colosseum three times though until I got bored. But I didn't like XD because it was cheap IMO. They used a lot of the same things in Colosseum, it felt like playing it again. In fact, I've had XD for over a month and it was so boring I just finished it a few days ago. But yeah the regular GB/GBC/GBA games are definitly the best.