4th Gen So, HeartGold, SoulSilver… whatcha getting?

[kyandipoppp]

Pre-ordered SoulSilver. :D At first, I only chose that one because I'm a big Bleach anime fan, and 'Soul' reminded me of Bleach. xP But it turns out that SS has some of my fav Pokemon, so yay for me!

 

[Skystrike]

(I'm back....xD)

I know I'm getting both, even though I won't play SS. :P
(I'll probaly like the "bulky" boxes they come in.)

 

[PunkySTAR]

I was originally leaning towards HeartGold but in the end I got a pre order for SoulSilver. I personally like the exclusives better. Maybe I can talk my brother into buying HG! lol :classic:

 

[thedestinedblade]

I was gonna pre-order Heart Gold on Amazon, but thanks to me not paying attention, I accidentally picked Soul Silver. Don't feel like changing the order now either. Not that big of a difference anyways. Though I won't be able to get Baltoy. :/

 

[harmonic ♫]

Oh nevermind that, I'm gonna get both >:]

One for my boss's son, and one for me :]

 

[Distortion World]

Well, after A LOT of saving, I'm getting HeartGold AND a DSi. I'm getting the DSi to trade my fav PKMN over.

But I'm probably not gonna play HeartGold right away, since I'm trying to hatch some E.V PKMN.

Sorry to all you Johto fans, but E.V training comes first for me.

 

[PoketalkCreator]

Heartgold or Soulsilver

Which one did you pick?......

 

[Flare Riqueza]

SoulSilver.

I kinda want HeartGold....whilst I'm scared of heights, I think it's better to have an epic duel atop a giant Pagoda in the middle of a major city, with a giant bird that last appeared when a pagoda burnt down, and created 3 legendaries out of 3 unknown pokemon that perished...


...when considered against battling a big, cool looking (looks cooler than Ho-oh, admittedly) bird in a cave with a waterfall, said bird having possibly lived in the now burnt down tower, and possibly possessing the ability to have created those whirlpools around the Whirl Islands.

Yeah, and the intro looks nicer.

So, in summary, picked SoulSilver, think HeartGold is better xD

 

[Famastar]

I chose Soul Silver, mainly because I prefer Lugia over Ho-oh.^ ^ (not that Ho-oh is bad)

 

[Eeohnex]

The main reason I picked Soul Silver over Heart Gold was because I preferred Soul Silver's intro. It's much better than the one that Heart Gold has. Another reason was that I like Groudon a lot more than Kyogre.

They aren't really that many differences in the game, except for the Pokémon exclusives.

 

[LeeBee]

I have SoulSilver.
I picked it because, basically I much prefer Silvery things than Golden things.. (>ω<＊)

 

[redsaber5859]

i have both, i liked hg so much i pre ordered the jp version!

 

[Eurydice]

i have both but i like soulsilver better because 1. lugia is better than ho-oh and 2. silver is better than gold. ^_^

 

[DEZTROY4]

Heart Gold. bro got silver.

 

[adam545454]

I prefer Heartgold becuase soulsilver 70 lugia is easier to EV train :P

 

[ThePinkDragon]

SoulSilver. Hubbs got Heartgold.

 

[Xyrin]

Both I have. But I like SS better. But since I have all the events on HG I have to go with that one.

 

[bobandbill]

Merged with this thread which is a bit old but was well-established and has a poll, etc - might as well keep keeping it to the one thread.

 

[Waddle_Dee]

Both for sure. I absolutely loved the original Gold/Silver/Diamond.

 

[chella182]

I got SoulSilver. I had Gold originally but I always wished I had Silver. Plus, Lugia is way more badass than Ho-Oh imo.