4th Gen Starter Pokemon....

[Sweet Candace]

Cyndaquil, no doubt. I loved him more than any other starter. He was a very powerful force when I faced the E4 for the first time (Next to Poilwrath and Raichu).

 

[Dragonmaster91]

Who: Cyndaquil

Why: Oh, no reason really. He is the best of the best, and Typhlosion can rip Feraligatr apart! I learned that on Crystal...

 

[Momoko]

Lol Totodile all the way :)
I love how it evolves at lvl 30 and it looks awesome!!

 

[BassFace]

I'm strongly considering buying both HeartGold and SoulSilver - HeartGold for my main game, and SoulSilver to replay as much as I want.

In HeartGold (in which I'll be playing as Soul), I'm starting with Cyndaquil. This is the starter I usually pick in the second-gen games, though I have started with Chikorita before, too.

In SoulSilver (in which I'll be playing as Gold), I'm thinking of doing something I've never done before, and starting with Totodile. I've raised Cyndaquil and Chikorita before, but never Totodile. However, in the third and fourth generation games, my dominant starters were the water-types. I've come to really like the water-type starters, so I think Totodile will be great to train.

 

[Kleinchen]

Cyndaquil is my most favorite Pokemon ever(I even have a Typhlosion as part of my team in Diamond), and I've alwaysssss started with it in GSC, when I played Gold I started with it... So I will definitely be going with Cyndaquil! n.n <3333

 

[InsaneMetagross]

I'm going to chose totodile since that is what i chose when i was a kid playing silver.

 

[d[-_-]b]

Totodile, cuz im doing a Totodile Solo Run on youtube

 

[Ayselipera]

Chikorita! I used to use her all the time. *remembering*

 

[ghostofherooftime]

IMO Cyndaquil is the only choice. I always hated chikorita and totodile is OK

 

[Timbjerr]

stuck between Cyndaquil and Totodile...probably gonna be Cyndaquil though as there are more water-types readily available than fire-types in the wild...

...I just realized...one can actually use that to justify choosing the fire-type starter in every game. :P

 

[the drummer]

i'm prob gonna pick totodile, i picked him the first time i played silver and kicked butt

 

[Dillon_68]

Chikoria ftw, I love the underdogs!

 

[La Foudre]

Cyndaquiiiiiiil.<3 One of my favorite Pokemon, ever.

 

[fredfredburger722]

Totodile, just like in my old Gold version. Actually I'm getting HeartGold, choosing Totodile, and going to completely reassemble my old team (That's right Hoenn and Sinnoh, no love for you!) just to relive the greatest moments of MY first Pokemon game. Sigh... good times.

 

[Kerjo]

Cyndaquil, because he's my favorite and I just love Quilava (won't ever use Typhlosion unless it's to complete pokedex or battle Red). If I were to ever get Soul Silver I would use Chikorita and plainly I just don't like totodile. I perfer Politoed/Kingdra over him.

 

[Valen]

im definetely going to use cyndaquil :) all fire starters from each game i use

 

[Astinus]

When I heard that these remakes were going to happen, my first choice for my starter Pokemon was Cyndaquil. I like the Fire starters the most out of the games (with the exception of R/S/E), and Cyndaquil was my starter back in the "old days".

Then as time went on, I found that I actually like Totodile these days. And since I never played with Totodile in Silver, I figured that I would chose it for the first time with these remakes.

 

[Late]

Cyndaquil as nearly always. It evolves into my favorite TYPHLOSION!!! I had Cyndaquil when I first time played Gold and then it has been so many times with me, but not too many times. I also use fire starters. First time when I played Blue I picked up Charmander. In Gold Cyndaquil, in Ruby I picked Torchic and in Diamond I picked up Chimchar. I have tested them all but I like fire-types.

 

[Brendonwii]

I started of as Chickorita but i found it to be crap,
So I restarted and used cyndaquil.
Dunno why when I was little I always started of as a grass type.XD

 

[Waffle-San]

I'll join the Totodile bandwagen, it was my first ever pokemon and has been my favourite ever since. Plus I'm actually looking forward to using Feraligatr comeptitively (though I really should be using Gyarados instead......go Torrent go!) so that's just another plus!!