He did a total of 21 posts this game, including his sign-up post.
Seriously? How do we have two deathless nights in two different games, all on the same day? How? Have the mafia here grown so incompetent that they can't get anything done!
Shout outs to the doc that saved the victim. Keep that name in the back of your mind so you have an innocent to reveal later on.
EDIT: oh wait, Abby got N0'd as survivor? Shoot, nvmd then.
Oh, right. Makes sense. That's what I get for not reading thoroughly.
Calling the mafia incompetent. Not necessarily a townie move as it could be used to deflect attention away from him. Special mentioning the doctor (maybe in hopes for the doc to accidentally reveal?
idk). no tells.
Well, alright then, I'll randomly vote too. I'm tempted to vote for HM for that random vote, but I know the pain of being lynched for casting the first stone. Instead I'll pick at random
[Lynch] Sir Dolan because that dolphin offends me.
Random voting. tempted to vote for HM (third party) and decided to vote Sir Dolan (who was Don).
Really? I'm not seeing it. I mean, yeah, it's an empty question they asked, but do you really expect anything of anyone on D1?
Defended L'Belle (who later claimed vanilla townie with a sword) from gimme. Leaning town here if L'Belle's claim is to be believed.
Sweet, we don't have to lynch people. Had I known that from the start, I wouldn't have bothered with the random vote.
[Unlynch] SirDolan
[Lynch] No one
Switched votes to abstain after random voting. Last one to voted. bandwagoning on the abstain vote maybe?
Well done, brave Sir Dolan. Rest in peace valiant warrior. Makes me sorry I ever insulted those hideous, bulging dolphin eyes.
Nothing to see here.
I suppose I will [Lynch] Melody as well. Sparkin is uncc'd, while Melody has been pretty aggressive and no one else strikes me as scummy yet.
Lynched Melody who turned out to be Doctor. Tried to defend Sparkin' who was uncc'd townie. leaning on townie again here if Sparkin' is to be believed.
Not a problem at all. Enjoy the b-day, and I wish you a speedy recovery!
So... anyone think Bidoof is the fool? I thought Melody might be with all that ranting until she claimed doc.
Switched focus to Bidoof for fool from Melody. However, he tried to lynch Melody before (which isn't good if he thought Melody was the fool) fos here.
I disagree. The last thing a fool would want to claim is doc, since that makes the town afraid to lynch and makes the maf too eager to kill. Hats off to the fool that can win claiming doc, but smart money says you're better off cc'ing a vanilla inno.
Hmm. Point here. However, still certain fos since he tried to lynch Melody before (if he was thinking Melody is the fool) it doesn't add up.
I think I've made up my mind. No lynching won't get us anywhere, and I want answers on this whole Melody/doof/Gunner mess.
[Unlynch] No one.
[Lynch]Bidoof FTW
From his posts, I thought Bidoof was his latest suspect for fool and it's not akin to a townie to vote for a person they think is a fool.
I'm with Johnny on this one... it's odd how the maf spared Melody, especially since they don't have a roleblocker to neutralize her with. And without a cop to verify her identity... I'd like to know how many of their souls they sold to the devil to get so lucky.
Yes, Melody should claim visits so we can have the truth of it. I wouldn't go so far as claiming who she'll visit next - that'd just give the maf a free pass.
Oh, and mind you, it's also possible they're planning to use their Strongman on her... but that still begs the question why they didn't do it now.
Pointed out the existence of a Strongman. Strong townie reads from this post alone.
Well, ****. She was telling the truth after all, and it looks like one of the vanillas got a sword and used it on her. Back-up plan, anyone?
Nothing to see here. Just a reaction to doc dying.
Okay, hi there everyone. How nice of us to lynch the doc - now that I'm out of work, I can post my thoughts on it.
First off, I'll be a little less active from now on because I just got a new job. Doesn't mean I'm not scum, I just don't want anyone reading too much into me not posting as often as I normally would. Anyways, on to my reads.
Johnny's been so damn thorough on all his arguments that it's hard to fault him for gunning for Melody. I was suspicious of the doc claim myself, but I was also under the presumption that the maf left her alone because they didn't trust the claim as well. It'd be all too easy for Melody to be Karol from their perspective, trying to draw the maf kill.
I agree with the scumread of HyperMorian, and for that, I'll townread doof, Naku, SF, and Johnny. gimmepie as well. I think maf left that bandwagon alone, since none of them would want to be on it if it turns out doc got lynched. Other than that, I don't have anything to offer at the moment, there's been too much and too little going on at the same time. So much smoke blown over the Melody mess, and cop gone, we need to find scum fast and have something to work with.
[Lynch] HyperMorian
Weird wording at the start of the post. we didn't lynch the doc. Melody got straight up killed by L'Belle using her sword. He mentioned again that he was suspicious of the doc claim, which was real as he thought Melody was the fool (?). However, I don't like his presumption that maf let her alone because of bad claim. I think it would be very much easy to counter claim a doctor and call on the one who claimed it and push for a scum lynch. He then townread doof (despite thinking he was fool before) and thinking that maf want to be part of a bad town lynch. IMO, it's better to be part of a bad town lynch because you blend in easier and you could just say bandwagon got me. IDK.
Probably because they expect you to use it. I'm half surprised they didn't try giving me a fake sword yet. Then again, they should know by now I'm just unhinged, not brain-dead.
So no, don't use it. Odds are 2/3 by my accounting that the sword's fake. Unless maf is handing out fake vests... which would be bad.
And while I'm thinking about it, why the hell is Repede handing out swords? We need vests way more.
Advising me on not using my sword. It's a townie move as my sword is pretty much confirmed to be rigged at this point in time. I agree with his Repede's point though. We need vests.
Well... I can see why. Maf would be more than eager to use their sword "for the good of the town." If they hit town, it's not their fault, and if they hit maf, they're cleared inno for life. Case in point: me during the whole Werewolves mafia thing. Jesus Christ, I won that game by being the gunsmith's hitman and then eating his brains once I was done enjoying all his guns.
I already answered this. The point would stand if maf knew they were given a real sword. it would not if it is a rigged sword. In my case, I knew it was a rigged sword as I have mentioned.
Good point. At the same time, though, maf didn't have time to decide if it'd be wise to join the wagon or not - there were only around five people on when Melody got stabbed.
Trying to make sense of the melody vote. Five people is a lot in that time standards in my opinion.
Next two posts are claiming posts, one asking Karol to claim and another the claim cc?d by Fletch.
Every time I had itchy fingers, I ended up doing something awful... case in point, murdering a cop. Didn't feel like doing that again.
To top it off, I have an idea. Why not leave me and Fletch to duel it out? It means that the mafia is forced to pick between letting a vigilante murder one of them so they can take out gimmepie, or killing the vig, letting the blacksmith go free and having that maf get lynched the next day. They don't have a role blocker or extra kill stashed away, so there isn't any way for them to counter this strategy.
Last Bard post. First one was defending his game which we all know. Next one is asking him and Fletch to be left alone. He posited two situations. I'm not yet reading much into this action. It seems a good action at a glance but I haven't yet to see if there are other stuff I'm not seeing.