3rd Gen Which Johto Starter would you pick in Emerald?

[Agamo]

Cyndaquil I've got the other two in diamond

 

[thorsstar]

Cyndaquil is what i would choose b/c i used it in gold/crystal. lol.

 

[lmnopguy7]

I chose Totodile since it was my starter in G/S/C. Good times...

 

[Schala_25]

I always liked Cyndaquil. My favorite fire type starter overall, and probably my favorite starter of all time, so that would be my choice. I already have all three though.

 

[angelsavoir]

I would choose Cyndaquil! They where always my favorite.

 

[♣Gawain♣]

I go for the defensive Chikorita, since I like defensive pokemon.

 

[Haza]

I have not gotten that far in the game but I will choose Cyndaquil or even Totodile.

 

[evilishan]

Totodile, because I love the water.

 

[JollyRoger25]

Talking from a strictly stats point of view.....
Grass
Meganium
HP:80
AT:82
DF:100
SPAT:83
SPDF:100
SP:80
Total:525
Weakness:5
Resistance:4
Immunities:0
Normal:8
Most Powerful Move: Solarbeam Lv:61

Fire
Typhlosion
HP:78
AT:84
DF:78
SPAT:109
SPDF:85
SP:100
Total:534
Weaknesses:3
Resistance:5
Immunities:0
Normal:9
Most Powerful Move: Flamethrower Lv:60

Water
Feraligatr
HP:85
AT:105
DF:100
SPAT:79
SPDF:83
SP:78
Total:530
Weaknesses:2
Resistance:4
Immunities:0
Normal:11
Most Powerful Move: Hydro Pump Lv:55

According to the stats, Cyndaquil -> Typhlosion is the better of the three to choose, but then again, that depends on how you plan to use the pokemon.

 

[Shardwire]

I'll tell you who I seriously picked: Chikorita. =]

But I do love Cyndaquil as well, I was thinking about picking him.

 

[moments.]

I don't know who I would pick, but maybe Chickorita because I don't have one yet and she is awesome for supporting the team as a Meganium!

 

[kissing. raindrops]

Cyndaquil =)
I love him <3

 

[mtr12]

I have always used Chikorita in Crystal and Shiny Gold.

But I would be more interested in Bulbasaur. Because of Sleep Powder.

 

[Gulpin]

I'd take Totodile, but Cydaquil and Chikorita come in a close second. Totodile, because that was the one I got when first playing the G/S/C Games.

 

[JezzaRules]

Uhh, I'd probably roll a dice to choose. I dont mind any of them.

 

[Heiheipig]

Cydanquil. Totodile is nice too but Chikorita is just...weird.

 

[Hadim Sinan Pasha]

despite my love for Fire pokemon, after Blaziken, my favourite starter pokemon is Feraligatr, so I'd pick Totodile.

 

[deliriouspurple]

well i like cyndaquil, cyndaquil is awesome!

 

[Amaruuk]

Why, the same Johto starter I'd pick in Johto, Totodile! Cyndaquil's cool too, but how could I say no to a dancing blue crocodile?

 

[Aether]

Cyndaquil. If given the choice in any game, it will always be my starter.