4th Gen Which Starter?

[JP]

Cyndaquil <3 Love that thing.

 

[Lt_Nite]

Cyndaquil, my favorite <3!

 

[EagleVision1999]

I'll choose Cyndaquil just because I like it best. The whole evolution line.
Ob the other hand I never chose Totodile before...but meh, I'll stick with Cyndaquil

 

[Sigura]

Cyndaquil. I always name it Barbecue too.

 

[.Eevee-Chan]

Definately Chikorita on one of them.The other not so sure,it's a dead tie between the other two.

 

[ToraSushii]

I'm-a pick Cyndaquil. Because I love Cyndaquil.

 

[Mr.Kirby]

Chickorita for me just so I can experience the nostalgia of having my first level 100 pokemon Meganium once again. T_T

 

[Mike20PR]

i love totodile cuz feraligatr is a slick sob. but its gonna be tough cuz all three are great

its the first gen that gave me so much trouble deciding on who to choose

 

[Wish]

Totodile.

It was my very first pokemon. Ever. It was my first choice back in the Second Generation. It also happened to be my first level 100 Pokemon as well. I would choose Totodile for nostalgic reasons.

 

[Cham]

It is a very hard choice. Gold and Silver was the only generation where I like all 3 starters equally. If I had to pick one though, I'd probably say Cyndaquil since I have so many water pokemon I like, I'd prefer them over Toto.

 

[Lady Gaga]

Heart Gold - Cyndiquil

Soul Silver - Chikorita

 

[dude2207]

I always loved my Typhlosion. I mean, I believe all the Johto starters are pretty balanced, right? Cyndaquil has always been my favourite, and I'm kinda reluctant to let it evolve, actually. It's my favourite starter, so I'm definitely picking it when I start.

i had one in silver so cyndaquil

 

[white lancer]

Depends on my mood at the time, but Totodile is my favorite. I like 'em all, though. ;)

 

[Klippy]

Totodile for sure. My favorite starter ever. XD; I think it'd be cool if they let you get all three eventually, much like in Yellow. :D

 

[Dextrose]

I have a soft spot for Totodile. And the Everstone. Together they are love.

 

[Stash23]

Cyndaquil; hands down!
Out of all of the gen starters, Cyndaquil just managed to squeeze into my heart! xD Also, it was my first fire type that wasn't um, the right way of saying it -- society expected. I choose Cyndaquil because it appealed to me, not just because everyone else choose it.

 

[Kokuo]

I'm picking Totodile.
I picked Totodile back in Silver so I'll pick it in Soul Silver too.

 

[Sublime]

Totodile <3
That thing would look so cute following me around :3

 

[chanchimi]

I usually go for fire types, but I'm going to start with Totodile =D

 

[Lover's Kite]

Totodile. I've always picked the water-type starter, in every game; always. :D
(but occasionally when I restart the games I choose the grass-types~)