4th Gen Which Starter?

[Pheya]

Knowing myself, I'd SAY Totodile, but pick Cyndaquil after all, because I just adore Fire Pokémon.

 

[zerwey]

Cyndaquil; I always go with the Fire starter. Though Totodile's superevolved form looks awesome.....=D

 

[Astinus]

It's a choice between Totodile and Cyndaquil. Cyndaquil was my starter on my first Silver game, so if I choose Cyndaquil, it'll help relive the experience from before. But Totodile is currently my favorite out of the three starters.

I'll probably just choose Cyndaquil on my SoulSilver game, and trade over a Totodile from my HeartGold. Just because I'll go with the Fire starter in the first place, as I tend to do.

 

[Bay]

Most likely will go with Cyndaquil since he's my favorite starter when I played Gold. That, and also I was able to get through the gyms quicker with that little guy. XD

 

[Xebelleon]

Cyndaquil.

I'll compliment story mode with other Pokemon. Like Abra, Ghastly and Pidgey.

 

[Ivysaur]

Cyndaquil. Beating Morty with a Flame Wheel is one of my dear childhood memories, for strange it may sound, and I'd love to do it again XD

 

[Inferno1]

I always get both games in the end anyway but i thought as if i was never going to get the other starters so i picked totodile.
For me thought it will go
Heart Gold Cydaquill
Soul Silver Totodile

 

[Tyrantrum]

As always, I'm starting with my beloved Cyndaquil! <3

Also, Typlosion is FTW! XDDDD;

And because of the kinds of types the gyms have, Cyndaquil makes it easier for you! :D

 

[Sweet Smoochum]

If Tododile's sprite is just as cute as the DPP one, probably that one. I love Chikorita w/ all my heart and Cyndaquil is amazing, but Tododile is the one that I have given the least attention to in the past. After seeing Chikorita following the main character, I'll probably end up getting both games so I can keep doing a new game in one of them. ^_^ The DPP sprite of Tododile is the cutest Tododile sprite I have ever seen compared to the original sprites of Tododile. (Besides, I already have Chikorita in Platinum. Its egg hatched on my birthday. ^_^)

 

[Silhouette]

I would have to say Cyndaquil. I like Totodile, and I never really use Chikorita or it's evolutions. Plus, the nostalgia.

 

[Cheesymitten]

Totodile, it's the only starter pokemon i've never stared with :/

 

[bruteroot]

I'll be going with Chikorita! I love that guy

 

[Shiny]

Chikorita, after G&S came out, I always liked Totodile but for the last year, I've enjoyed Chikorita more.

 

[Nalu93]

I'm getting Chikorita because I always used her,maybe Cyndaquil if I want to change

 

[auragirl]

I'm choosing Totodile.

I always choose the water type the first time around. Besides, i love totodile! It's always been one of my favorates.

 

[Glaceon_]

This would be a very hard decision for me to make... because I really liked the Johto Starters... but in the end, I will probably end up going with Totodile. Likewise with which game I'm going to buy, Totodile was the Starter I chose on the first Generation II game I had; Gold. So I think nostalgia reigns supreme for me, this year. XD

 

[PatJamma]

Cyndaquil by far! I remember when I didn't know how to get to kanto way back then and I had a lvl 100 typhlosion from killing the E4 so much before I figured it out

 

[Floris2Burn]

cyndaquil!

always the fire starter... except the d/p then (the new dp pkmn don't look so good, especially... *shivers*)

only if one of the others would evolve into some dragon i'd reconsidder taking an other then the fire.. but they don't. *starts dreaming*

 

[CrazyCubone]

The only thing I hated about Gold/Silver was the starters. It's so hard to pick one because they're all so equally AMAZING! Seriously, Johto starters are the best out of ANY generation. But I think I'll choose Cyndaquil.

 

[-Leaf]

Hard time between toto and chiko.