4th Gen Will You Return Shuckie?

[WisherWisherWish]

As we all know, if we want to get an easy Shuckle, there's a free one at Cianwood City.

It seems like the rival threatened Mania, Shuckie's Trainer, into giving them their rarest PKMN, which is Sneasel.

But here's the catch.

The trainer expects the Shuckle back later on in the game.

Luckily, you have a choice to giving him it back or not.

Me personally, I'd keep it.

How about you? Will you be the Good Samaritan or be as low as Silver?

 

[yoshikiller995]

Well if I even remembed to collect the Shuckle, I would stuff it in my box and forget about it forever.

 

[-Leaf]

its hard as leet to train him. I don't think i would even take him anyway.
And how you got that the rival threatened and took the sneasel?

 

[Team Rocket's Raichu]

You could give it back? Man 9 years and I haven't given it back. Well I guess I'll fire up Crystal and return it. I hope the man hasn't noticed it's been gone so long.

 

[The Fourteenth Doctor]

I haven't even picked it up in my game, i would probably stick it in the pc and never bother to return it

 

[Eggie Poo Poo]

OMG I never actually thought about keeping it I always gave it back, damn why didn't I think of that !!! s'pose it's not the right thing to do ... to steal it =\

 

[Tudj]

I guess after a while I would probably give it back, I guess I would want it back if I were him. But half the time hes just in my Pc left there.

 

[Alucia]

well you can catch them now so i wont even bother taking it

 

[Mitchman]

I cruelly take it cause I actually find it useful for my team.

 

[Creqaw]

I never knew that you had to give it back O_O

 

[Megaman765]

Not sure, If I wanted to do something epic, I'd use that shuckle against the rival's sneasel :p

 

[Anzel]

I could have sworn that I befriended it once and the person let me keep it x3;; To be honest.

 

[msdmario]

I always kept the Shuckle in the box on every playthrough for all the 2nd generation games. In my current Heart Gold file, I have already caught a wild Shuckle of my own since I was farming for some items so I have no use for the free Shuckle.

 

[:3]

I actually never use it. It just sits in my box
And the Weird nickname I dont like either.

Shuckie right?
Eh.

 

[ShinyMeganium]

I'd give it back I guess. You can breed it/catch another one by rock smashing rocks, and that'd be probably better...I hate gift Pokemons/in game Pokemons anyways cause of their stupid nicks etc.

Why did it give you a Shuckle then took it back to begin with...? I never heard that you should bring it back.

 

[Lady Gaga]

Its just a game, the people dont matter x3
Id keep it :/

 

[The Sceptile King]

silver is happy of all these evil people like me and him

 

[Kokuo]

I'll return it to him, I may breed it if I'm too lazy to smash rocks for one.

 

[Ellie]

I didn't return it in GSC (mainly because I forgot like many others, haha), so I probably won't return it or Kenya the Spearow. Plus it's extra IDno's for the Lucky Number Show :P

 

[JP]

I don't even think I ever went to get it in the original games. I probably wont this time around too. :P