Gah, I don't know, man. I'm gonna have to either go with "Ghost Reveries" or "Blackwater Park," which was the first album I ever picked up by them. Both were amazing...so it's really a toss-up between those two for me. Watershed was by no means "bad," just not what I had expected in their new album. Still love the song "The Lotus Eater, though. Oh! and Hessian Peel, even if it took me like 3 days to realize the lyrics are sung backwards XD;