Recent content by Yoshikko

if elf and i don't finish it today then he gets the win is what we decided on! not been in the headspace for it lately but we'll try today

pm'd

elf and i are battling this weekend

NOOOOOO

there are no rules saying people can't look up replays. you haven't convinced me with any of your arguments why replays should be required to post publicly. also, no one can claim they won when they haven't, because they still have to send the replays to the tour host/mod. so how would that...

because it is! it deals with faeries and checks ferrothorn

but control only reaches so far, there's nothing stopping people from sharing information privately anyway, no matter what is ultimately decided, or using alts to play games and thus disable people from looking up their replays, there are countless ways to go around the rules from either sides...

i think he meant optional public, required private! so if you want to post them publicly that would be okay, as long as if you don't you at least DM them privately. that's how I read it. anyhow, whether counter teaming is a problem or not doesn't really matter for me, it's just that it makes...

https://www.pokecommunity.com/showthread.php?t=429586 please read this thread if you care about the replay rules stuff

i'll start with saying i prefer option B by a mile. there are enough strategic reasons for not wanting to post replays publicly. sharing replays privately also does not prevent users to go and look for the replays themselves in the replay database, in which they must be saved either way. i feel...

Discussion Hi all! In this thread we will discuss the rule regarding replays for future tournaments. Introduction Currently, it is a requirement to post the battle replays after a round is won (best of three), so that the victory may be confirmed by the host. There has been some confusion...

as former battle server staff and current contender my opinion is that it would be fair to let the userbase vote on whichever rule they find fairest, as it will affect them the most. in light of this i want to vote for the second option. reasoning: posting replays functions as a confirmation...

ggs! i sent chase both replays

beat gimmepie! ggs man :) we agreed not to post the replays, it was my request as the winner and gimmepie was okay with it and i sent chase both replays so he can confirm

i'm 'gloom' on showdown