Design-a-Pokemon Event Judging!

Gulpin

poisonous
    • 3,270
    Posts
    18
    Years
    • Seen Jan 16, 2017

    Completed Pokemon

    ` Eos Aduro; Ariendo [Complete]
    Spoiler:

    ` BlackTux007; Soidon [Complete]
    Spoiler:

    ` Chronic; Guilottine [Complete]
    Spoiler:

    ` Seadiga; Dratyion [Complete]
    Spoiler:

    ` Logiedan; Helspon [Complete]
    Spoiler:

    ` ShinjisLover; Morisu [Complete]
    Spoiler:
    ` sky_queen3; Minusle [Complete]
    Spoiler:

    ` RHLaehnart; Caliodes [Complete]
    Spoiler:

    ` ZOMGCODY; Blazehlisk [Complete]
    Spoiler:

    ` iDawg; Sqwagblu [Complete]
    Spoiler:

    ` Epsikon Sato; Amazi [Complete]
    Spoiler:
     
    Last edited:
    I just wanted to know, an idea of mines for judging. Do you all have MSN?
     

    Completed Pokemon Cont.

    ` n!T3_w0Lf; Lastic [Complete]
    Spoiler:


    Complete? Pokemon

    ` Get Out Of My Bath,Poliwag; Electafli [Complete?]
    ` Wi-fi Battler; Incendue [Complete?]
    ` raulaun; Magnetar [Complete?]
    ` Cherri; Necroid [Complete?]
    ` pwnt2j; Grafca [Complete?]
    ` kitsukitty; Illusion [Complete?]
    ` halomarin; Blazedon [Complete?]
    ` Crosell; Dohydra [Complete?]
    ` The Sceptile King; Flameel [Complete?]
    ` Chibi Robo; Jeliton [Complete?]
    ` pokemonrockliz78; Umbreus [Complete?]
    ` Latiace; Multiplier [Complete?]
    ` lx_theo; Deiogus [Complete?]
    ` 007manyo; Wingachu [Complete?]
    ` animeFTW; Seahale [Complete?]
    ` Darkrai-is-MINE; Unos [Complete?]
    ` Smizzly_Bob; Jormundrake [Complete?]
    ` Pachy; Steelchu [Complete?]
    ` PokemonCrazy; Bonvee [Complete?]
    ` Angela; Starizard [Complete?]
    ` Hamako-chan; Persnake [Complete?]

    Participants Without an Entry

    ` Rich Boy Rob
    ` Screw the rules, I have green hair!
    ` ReyЯey-Pчoи
    ` lucaslucario
    ` Spicy
    ` smexyjuliet
    ` minchan
    ` x.Rayquaza.x
    ` Demonic Aura
    ` Anastasia.R
    ` drivr3joe
    ` Juu-Chan
    ` Zero-the hero of light
    ` Tsukimaru
    ` Mormo
    ` killanotha1
    ` dtallan
    ` iPingu
    ` Metal Sunlight
    ` Father-nature
    ` Golden Apple
    ` MessiahForHire
     
    Last edited:
    My idea was that if we all had MSN, then we could instantly chat and judge each entry on Monday. I know I have it, Kaori has it, and Zet.

    I'm not sure about the others though.
     
    I can't think of any way that we can all judge them. We can:

    All judge each one then add the answer and find the most common score.
    or
    Divide each entry and each judge those ones by ourselves.

    Crap.. I'm going to have to move the 'due' date up to sometime tommorow... I just realised that I can only get on from about 9:00 PM on Monday.
     
    Hmm, I find it easier if we were all on at the same time, but I know that is hard to do as we all have things to do and we all live in different areas. However, I believe if we all individually judge them, and then probably add up each score, the top two with the highest points can came out victorious. I'm not sure on how we'll work this out, but that is my idea.

    Also, sign ups end in about fifty minutes. O_o
     
    I had to change the times, check the main thread. We will start to judge tomorrow.
     
    Tomorrow at twelve sounds good to me then, at least we've gotten that pretty much cleared up.

    The question is, how will we judge?
     
    Lets individually judge each one. Post JUST THE SCORES so we don't have humongous posts to scroll through, add up the scores and divide it by the number of judges. First of all, we can go ahead and start with the Completed ones. At 12, non-completed ones will be considered completed.

    I'm going to go ahead and start judging the completed ones. I'll also put them in the first post of this thread.
     
    That sounds loke a pretty good plan. I don't think I will be home to judge at the time of 12, but sometime afterwards in the day I will get to it.

    Now that sign ups are closed and all we have to do it more so wait for others to have theirs completed, then I think it'll be a bit easier for us.
     
    Yeah. I'm going to go ahead and judge the complete ones. Also, I'm giving points for presentation. I think we also need to have winners for:

    Most Creative Name:
    Most Creative Artwork:
    Most Creative New Ability:
    Most Creative New Move:
    Most Creative Evolution Method:
    Most Creative Dex Entry:
    Best in Show:

    These will go to those who don't win 1st or 2nd place.

    These are the completed Entries, and their judging from me. There are only 6 others.



    Logiedan – 155
    Chronic – 150
    ShinjisLover – 145
    = GPR = – 138
    raulaun – 110
    Cherri – 110
    Angela – 110
    kitsukitty – 110
    Skip Shot – 110
    lx_theo – 115
    halomarin – 108
    Get Out Of My Bath,Poliwag – 107
    Chibi Robo – 107
    Pachy – 105
    RSLaehnart – 105
    Wi-fi Battler – 102
    Rich Boy Bob – 102 (72)
    Seadiga – 101
    ZOMGCODY – 101
    Latiace – 101
    PokemonCrazy – 101
    Spicy – 100
    Smizzly_Bob – 100
    Hamako-chan – 99
    Crosell – 99
    Eos Aduro – 95
    BlackTux007 – 91
    animeFTW – 89
    The Sceptile King – 86
    pwnt2j – 85
    007manyo – 82
    Darkrai-is-MINE – 76
    pokemonrockliz78 – 72
    n!T3_w0Lf – 70
     
    Last edited:
    Then I'm guessing they added extra, or the limit isn't 100 points. ;D

    There's lots of stuff to judge.
     
    Well..I'm unsure to calculate a score..
    But from what i saw..
    The two winners would be

    1. Chronic
    2. =GPR=/ Logiedan
     
    I was evaluating all of them depending on what they gave us.
    I judged based on how well their layout was, how much work was put into it, their originality, and how realistic everything was formatted, plus the extras they might have included themselves.

    It wasn't as hard as I thought once I figured out who really put much effort into it. Here are the places I thought that were acceptable after judging.

    1st Place: Logiedan
    2nd Place [Tie]: Chronic/ShinjisLover

    As for the honorable mentions included, that was pretty hard to decide for each category.
    I don't know what others might have gotten.
     
    Lets go with this:

    1st Place - Logiedan / Chronic
    2nd Place - ShinjisLover/ = GPR =

    Blazers said:
    How did you get past 100 if theres only 100 points?
    Click to expand...

    Bonuses for adding extra items, and bonuses for going out of their way, and for presentation.
     
    Last edited:
    deku said:
    Lets go with this:

    1st Place - Logiedan / Chronic
    2nd Place - ShinjisLover/ = GPR =
    Click to expand...

    I think I'll go with that, because it seems pretty stable to me. All four of them put up a pretty nice design in the Pokémon as well as backing it up with their different aspects and more. I believe if it is alright with everyone else, then we can announce it before midnight and then have one of the higher staff award them their prize.
     
    It seems pretty good to me. I was looking through each one earlier today, reading up each characteristic and more on their Pokémon and all four Logiedan, Chronic, ShinjisLover, and =GPR= had really done a great job. They were each detailed with more than we might have asked for, and they were very original and realistic when it came to their moves, stats, and more. So, I think it is a pretty good choice to have them tie each place.
     
    Yeah, I agree that those four should tie in each place. I doubt we can actually figure out a first and second place out of all them.
     
    You must log in or register to reply here.
    Back
    Top