3rd Gen FR vs. LG vs. Emerald (revised)

[AdamHays]

Here is the first hot thread poll ever created in this sub-forum,lets see if minds have changed and what the new members think.

original Idea Made By: DarkRaikou

 

[Unknown Hero]

emerald more stuff in it but props to frlg for making me reminisce (sp?) sooo much

 

[Mr Cat Dog]

Fire Red and Leaf Green really should be conjoined - they're basically the same game remember. All there is is different Pokemon to catch. But still... with all of Emerald's new features - I'll have to go with that.

 

[C Sherbii S]

I guess I like emerald, because i have played it more

 

[salamenceruler04]

I really like fire red..but i never got to play emerald yet...so im not decided yet, if this is still here when i get it ill post it if i like it ...(but i dout it will be)

 

[cranium]

emerald because theres more to get excited about

 

[nicscool]

I can't wait for emerald! It means I can finish my nationaldex.

 

[Mr Cat Dog]

I can't wait for emerald! It means I can finish my nationaldex.

Unless you've got Japanese games, you can't complete it without Celebi - the only one to be left out of these Wonder Post events. So... you can get 385, but you'll be missing Celebi.

 

[Frostweaver]

You really can't compare all of them... they all contribute to the metagame with the use of move tutors, making all of them essential for game play. It's not like having Emerald means that FRLG's move tutor is completely useless for example. Without FRLG, you won't be having free rock slides. Yet without Emerald, there's no free elemental punches then.

 

[Kenta-kun]

I can't wait for emerald! It means I can finish my nationaldex.

You can technically finish the NationalDex with Fr/LG, R/S, & Colosseum. I don't think Emerald is required

 

[AdamHays]

Wow this didnt do that good. :laugh:

 

[Toothache]

Unless you've got Japanese games, you can't complete it without Celebi - the only one to be left out of these Wonder Post events. So... you can get 385, but you'll be missing Celebi.

Did Japan ever get Jirachi? I know they got Celebi from the bonus disc in Colosseum instead of Jirachi, but did they ever get Jirachi legally?

 

[Pikawolf]

Leaf Green is the best in my opinion. Even though I like all the games, I think that Leaf Green was more in depth, even though it's virtually the same as Fire Red. I thought that Ruby/Sapphire was a bit too short, although, I still adore the game. ^^

~Kelsey

 

[Star Crossed Dreamer]

I pick Emerald because it has way more features than FR/LG, but they have the Sevii Islands.

 

[mew42003]

I can't wait till Emrald!!!!!!!!!!