May vs. Dawn--Who's Better

Who's Better ?

  • Total voters
    126
Status
Not open for further replies.
LAWL NECROPOSTING.

Anyway, I hate both May and Dawn. However, since I never watched Advance Generation, I saw less of May, which makes her a bit less annoying in my mind.
 
Tokyopoprock said:
I think that May was really whiny and apathetic; she was always afraid and I found her simply annoying. I like Dawn much better because she shows bravery and determination much more frequently.
Click to expand...

Yeah I agree with you. Dawn is a fighter and somehow she remains girly.
 
This is a toughie, Two very hard choices.

With Dawn the things I prefer much more than May is her clothes and her attitude.

Dawn is is a battler and May isn't, I never did really like the whole contest idea with May. May has weird clothes and her voice can get really on my nerves. I still prefer Misty out of the two of them but all in all my vote goes to Dawn.
 
To me, they're both winy, but Dawn is even more clueless than may was in her beggining stages, but Dawn is clearly gifted, whereas may just had to work super hard, so i think if they were to start at the same time, May would've been a MUCH better coordinator, but as time past, prolly about their 5th competition, Dawn would pull ahead, but i think they're pretty even
 
May had much better character development early on in the series; we knew she was a klutz, a bit girly, not very experienced and all that: plus she had awesome rivals who assisted her development and her relationship with Ash and Brock was more of a student-teacher one.

Dawn is just...there, I guess. She doesn't have many qualities that help her stand alone as a character. She borrows qualities from May, some from Misty, and even a few from the early Ash as well. That too, she's not really interesting HERSELF, y'know? I mean...Pochama and Buizel are much more interesting than she is...and even they've got more character development than she has. And her rivals are kinda dull: Zoey is your typical good-character, and Kengo is as well. Drew was cool in the beginning, and Harley is just...Harley XD

So overall, May >>> Dawn.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top