Pixel Art Duel #6 Fireworks vs. Hi-Techneon

[countryemo]

Pixel Art Duel #6
Fireworks vs. Hi-Techneon​

Introduction

Since the first went so well, why not another?!
Welcome! This thread is to vote for who you think should win this duel.
Whose pixels are more impressive than the others? You decide!

Rules

1. No voting for yourself.

2. When voting, you must include comments on why you voted for the specific sprite.
Critcisim is appriciated also.

3. Don't be harsh on sprites, this is for fun after all!

Contestants

Theme: G/S/C Devamp
Species: Hoenn vs. Unova

Fireworks
Devamp of Shuppet

Hi-Techneon
Devamp of Hydreigon

Have fun!​

 

[Conan Edogawa]

My vote goes for Fireworks, simply because it fits the GSC style of spriting(sort of disproportional, weird looking) better than the other.

 

[The 100 Mega Shock]

It's not great, but I would definitely give this vote to Hi-Techneon, because it follows G/S/C colour and shading style far better than Fireworks' piece. wait who even said this was gsc themed **** this i'm out if it doesnt even have a consistent theme

 

[Logiedan]

It's not great, but I would definitely give this vote to Hi-Techneon, because it follows G/S/C colour and shading style far better than Fireworks' piece. wait who even said this was gsc themed **** this i'm out if it doesnt even have a consistent theme

True, but might as well change it to G/S/C devamp now considering that they both fit the style. I love how the title was "Pixel Art Duel #5." XD

edit: fixed the thread.

 

[Dorandragon]

@Fireworks: you got my vote in this one. while it may not look like it is GSC style truely(more like RBY), its definitly better than the hydreigon. For one, you didnt just resize the sprite from BW, and for two, it was scratched as far as I can tell. Scratching is a sign of a more acomplished spriter in my opinion.

@Hi-techneon: it looks nice, but the fact that its just a resize of hydreigon made me dissapointed. I'm sure you could have done better if you knew what you needed to do to make it a legitimate GSC sprite, but you used what you had. Better luck next time :)

 

[~Kian~]

Hi-techneon get's my vote, i think: its a good sprite looks almost identical to its original sprite, plus the sprite is more challenging, nice work..

~Kian~

 

[miju-kun]

I vote for Fireworks. His sprite is more...G/S/C like. (kinda weird looking but that's what G/S/C sprites are supposed to look like right?)

 

[blackmoonflower]

Fireworks has my vote for this one. I look at that Shuppet and think of the old games.

The Hydreigon looks far too complex and detailed to look like the old sprites. But it does have its own sense of style to it.

Good job, both of you.

 

[Chiar]

Voted for Hi-Techneon because Shuppet is a really simple Pokemon to draw, unlike Hydreigon. Also Shuppet looks more like a RBY, not GSC devamp.
I like both sprites, though. <:

 

[Logiedan]

We have a tie here, ladies and gentlemen. So I opened the poll up for another week, votevotevote! :D

 

[Conjurer]

I find it hard to decide, but in the end I voted for Hi-Techneon, because it's more GSC-like. Yes, I really think that.

 

[Logiedan]

And the winner is...

Hi-Techneon and his Hydreigon Devamp!

Congratulations! You've won with one point ahead of Fireworks.

Until next time.
​