4th Gen Great Marsh or Safari Zone

[ILoveRobots]

Great marsh looked better. So I choose that one

 

[feralig8rx]

I have to say that I was not happy with the Great Marsh to say the least. I was waiting for that whole, "wait, where am I? I'm running out of steps so I better find that guru fast!" like I had in the Safari Zone. Like Mentalii said earlier, the sinking in the sand thing was funny at first but became extremely aggravating to deal with towards the latter parts.

I also didn't really feel like I needed to go to the Great Marsh for any reason. The Safari Zone at least made me look forward to a HM Surf at the end, and I had to get it if I wanted to move on to Cinnabar.

 

[Deliciousfruit233]

I have to say that I was not happy with the Great Marsh to say the least. I was waiting for that whole, "wait, where am I? I'm running out of steps so I better find that guru fast!" like I had in the Safari Zone. Like Mentalii said earlier, the sinking in the sand thing was funny at first but became extremely aggravating to deal with towards the latter parts.

I also didn't really feel like I needed to go to the Great Marsh for any reason. The Safari Zone at least made me look forward to a HM Surf at the end, and I had to get it if I wanted to move on to Cinnabar.

Wasn't the Surf HM only there in the R/B/Y Safari Zone?

 

[FrostPheonix]

Hated the marsh. Due to getting stuck and also the fact that you never knew what pokemon you might find.

 

[The Corrupt Plague]

The Safari Zone. The ability to customize it was certainly a nice touch but it has its flaws. This still beats slogging through mud in the Great Marsh though.

 

[Khall]

I guess I choose the Safari Zone, but I wish they would bring back how it was in R/B/Y - lots of decent Pokemon only obtainable there, and none of this "waiting a day" or getting frustrated from getting stuck in mud. Y'know, just walking around with a time limit, finding cool and rare Pokemon without all these added on things.

 

[RivalGator]

The Safari Zone. I hated the Great Marsh. I couldn't stand the way it looked, the way you got stuck, the kind of Pokemon you caught. I loved the Safari Zone.

 

[Sector]

The Great Marsh was annoying. I do not like the getting stuck in the mud part. But it's something new to deal with in the game I guess. I don't do Safari Zone though..I seem to get everything through trades and breed the Pokemon to start from their birth to level 100's.

 

[miltankRancher]

Safari zone definitely. It has more excitement, and I hate the swamp. too annoying.

 

[SPEEDIE]

Safari Zone, although the idea of getting blocks and waiting to get certain pokemon can be annoying, I would rather wait than get stuck in mud, the Tram things in the great marsh I though were quite neat though

 

[Yoshikko]

I actually detest the Safari zone because I could NEVER EVER find HM03 in it in Yellow version when I was little, my friend always had to do it for me and it just sucked bad. I don't really care for the great Marsh lol.

 

[Raizhu]

Safari Zone. It's a bit tricky to figure out, but it's worth it. And I didn't like being stuck in the mud.

 

[Raichupacabra]

The Safari Zone. It had access to so many Pokemon from the start and after a certain amount of days you could get psuedo-legendaries like Bagon.

The Great Marsh annoyed me so much. The Pokemon aren't even that good aside from the occasional Yanma or Carnivine and getting stuck in the mud every step was a pain.

 

[Dave666]

Safari Zone without a doubt, I HATE with all my soul, mind, heart and body the great marsh , always get stucked in the marsh -__-

 

[Klave]

I still don't understand the way to get rare Pokemon in the Safari Zone, but it is better than the muddy ol' marsh. :U

 

[Spades Slick]

To be honest, neither, I haven't really played at them a lot, and when I did, I disliked both of them.

 

[Infernal_Storm]

The great marsh had a lack of variety in pokemon and also was an annoyance to get around due to the deep swamp. The Safari Zone was kind of irritating with the waiting thing, but I got used to it and it's made up for with the rare pokemon anyway.

 

[Palamon]

I like the Great Marsh better. I like it better because in HG/SS the Safari Zone is too confusing and the Pokemon are too hard to catch.

 

[Melinda]

I prefer the Safari Zone. I hate getting stuck in the Great Marsh and having to spin around to get loose.

 

[Nick]

I hate them both. I never ever liked the Safari Zone (it was really only good for catching Dratini, Chansey, and Khangaskan in R/B/Y) and I never liked the concept of the Great Marsh. I think I liked that less than the Safari Zone, even.