Map Rating/Review Thread

[Binary]

I couldn't be stuffed hosting it, so it's an attachment.

Name: ----
Description: The palettes are saturated to give it a nice feel. Because I'm experimenting with them. The town is the starting town in my new hack, and I want some criticism, though I think it's as good as it gets for starting towns. I have inserted many tiles, I'm changing playing around with the palettes a bit.
Credits: Zel - Water Palette.
Kyledove - House Palette.

Rate: 9/10
Reason: It is lovely in its simplicity and nice choice of palletes. Nice use of the paths and the fences, they look very nice.
Suggestions: You could add some trees or anything in the empty gaps to not make the map have an empty feel to it. But nice work!

 

[Reaper 6]

I couldn't be stuffed hosting it, so it's an attachment.

Name: ----
Description: The palettes are saturated to give it a nice feel. Because I'm experimenting with them. The town is the starting town in my new hack, and I want some criticism, though I think it's as good as it gets for starting towns. I have inserted many tiles, I'm changing playing around with the palettes a bit.
Credits: Zel - Water Palette.
Kyledove - House Palette.

i would give you a 10/10 for this map everything is perfect

 

[Jirachi_961]

RATINGS: 5/10
REASON: Though the map is kinda well balanced, the error of the tiles are not very pleasing... Were you inseting and making new tiles? :\
SUGGESTION: The only thing I can suggest is that you should make those tiles more nicely done... I ain't no tiler, and so I can't go any further in that matter...
PICTURE of ERRORS:

Wow, i really didnt see the sloppy work that i had done.. lol. I redid the map, and took out the bad peices.



Is that what you were looking for?

EDIT: I see another map error, and i have just fixed it. The one at the exit of the town, right next to the left side of the tree.

 

[destinedjagold]

New RATINGS: 8/10
New REASON: It's looking way better now than the last time. ;) Although I kinda don't like the borders of the windows on those 2 houses on the top of the map, but still, the map's nice.
New SUGGESTION: You used the wrong end tile of the white fences.It's noticable in gameplay, though.

 

[Zeikku™]

Hey rate my map I attached it, it's my first big map... photobucket wouldn't let me upload it... :(
it's for a ruby hack

ratings please

 

[destinedjagold]

RATINGS: 8/10
REASON: Well, I like the map so much. :)
SUGGESTION: Nothing, I guess...

 

[Zeikku™]

thanks dude, i was quite unsure about the map, but it's nice of you to rate it :)

 

[~Red]

Hey rate my map I attached it, it's my first big map... photobucket wouldn't let me upload it... :(
it's for a ruby hack

ratings please

RATING: 9/10
REASON: It has everything a map needs, a good balance of everything.
SUGGESTION: The stairs on the left of the mountain are placed abit funny, its hard to explain but if you put the second one up one space and the third up two spaces then youll understand.

 

[Kristian]

Hey rate my map I attached it, it's my first big map... photobucket wouldn't let me upload it... :(
it's for a ruby hack

ratings please

Comment: The map is nicely Done, even through there's some tile errors, and some places are abit empty..

Suggestion: I suggest you to fill the top of the mountains abit..like insert some random mountains and such(on top, where the player can walk)

--Rate: 8/10

 

[Tropical Sunlight]

7/10

Because the stairs are a bit weird and I don't like the grass

 

[Zeikku™]

RATING: 9/10
REASON: It has everything a map needs, a good balance of everything.
SUGGESTION: The stairs on the left of the mountain are placed abit funny, its hard to explain but if you put the second one up one space and the third up two spaces then youll understand.

yeah, I realised that there is another tile for the 2nd flight of stairs, i'll insert those and fix that

Comment: The map is nicely Done, even through there's some tile errors, and some places are abit empty..

Suggestion: I suggest you to fill the top of the mountains abit..like insert some random mountains and such(on top, where the player can walk)

--Rate: 8/10

yeah i'll do that, thanks man

7/10

Because the stairs are a bit weird and I don't like the grass

thats a tile problem...I plan on changing the grass anyways...

 

[Binary]

Hey rate my map I attached it, it's my first big map... photobucket wouldn't let me upload it... :(
it's for a ruby hack

ratings please

Rate: 8/10
Reason: Vincent rombase mixed with Kyledoves tiles don't match too much, but it looks ok ^^
I found a few errors, but they're only minor. I like the way you placed the mountains, great job! The trees are placed in a square like shape, and thats not so good. Anyways, th map looks good.
Suggestions: Add some matching grass tiles, and place some scattered trees

 

[Zeikku™]

okay thanks celebi, the grass tiles are from zelda :D
I'll fix up all errors soon :D

 

[/Circa]

I've got another map I made for fun.

Name: ---
Description: Just a map I made for fun, tried to make it a bit more natural than other towns. The tree palette has been changed slightly, I added some more tiles. Again it's in the attachments because i'm too lazy too host it :).

Edit:
Oops, wrong map xP.
Argh, attachment isn't working. I have to upload it now...

Spoiler:

 

[destinedjagold]

eheheh... I thought my computer was the one with problems for not showing the map. anyways...
RATINGS: 8/10
REASON: Well, it's peaceful-looking. I also like the balance of the map...
SUGGESTION: Nothing, I guess... :\

 

[~Red]

I've got another map I made for fun.

Name: ---
Description: Just a map I made for fun, tried to make it a bit more natural than other towns. The tree palette has been changed slightly, I added some more tiles. Again it's in the attachments because i'm too lazy too host it :).

Edit:
Oops, wrong map xP.
Argh, attachment isn't working. I have to upload it now...

Spoiler:

RATING: 9/10
REASON: A very interesting mix of subtle tiles that fill the space nicely. I love the way you improvise with the red roof tiles.
SUGGESTION: The johto grass near the bottom of the map wouldnt grow naturally diagonally, i know im being picky but it was the first thing my eyes laid on so...

 

[Neti]

First: Im new to this forum so i cant post any images or links, youll have to copy the given url to see the images ;-)

All Maps dont have names, the Game is Firered.
The Grass Tiles on the routes are not mine, i forgot where i took them from (sry for that). Im not going to publish any hack with this tiles, these maps were made just for fun!


Route 1:
eugenier.eu.ohost.de/poke/route1.jpg
Comments: There are some tile errors at the thin trees, ill take care of that.

Route2:
eugenier.eu.ohost.de/poke/route2.jpg
Comments: The left Part is nearly the original Nintendo one

Route 3:
eugenier.eu.ohost.de/poke/route3.jpg
Comments: Hmm none

A Town:
eugenier.eu.ohost.de/poke/bam.jpg
Comments: A Remake of Cerulean City

Region Map:
eugenier.eu.ohost.de/poke/map2.jpg
Comments: I cant manage to insert in a rom, im too stupid to do that...

 

[blaster911]

Hey I made a map Yesterday
rate it!:classic:

Spoiler:

OR ELSE.........L.O.L.

 

[adamb241]

3/10- Your map as a lot of errors.....Sorry...It also doesn't look natural....Too many random things every where.......

 

[Neti]

i think ive seen this map before when i was reading this thread...

well...
rating: 6/10
reason: i like the shape of the map and there are some good iddeas (eg the house on top the hill). but i notice several tile errors (path on the top-left hill, grass on the big hill) and i dont like the big amount of stones, flowers and bushes all at the same spot
suggestions: remake the border of the map and fix the things i mentioned above