Map Rating/Review Thread

[BlackRainbow*]

Epsilon: Your map its verry nice. I really like the tiles. But i'm not really the fan of tree paletts. but anyway great work. 9/10

 

[Wichu]

Snuggle: Change the ledge in the top-left, or remove the tree next to the left-most house, as jumping down the ledge there will get you stuck behind the house, with no way out.

 

[snuggle100]

ok thank you for the tips

 

[BlackRainbow*]

Here is the starting town of my hack plz rate:

Yirol Town

 

[Epsilon]

Here is the starting town of my hack plz rate:

Yirol Town

Nice,

but where did the new tileset go?

(8/10)

 

[Tropical Sunlight]

Hello,
does anybody know how big must be a region map (when you use Fly) in R/S/E/FR/LG?
I want a region map for Turquoise: Aqua Egg and I want to make it in D/P style.
If anyone can help me, please post. And answer it with pixels, not centimeters on inches.

When I finish the map I will post it here.
If this isn't the right topic, let me know about it.

 

[BlackRainbow*]

Epsilon: What do you mean with that "but where did the new tileset go?"

 

[danoftheworld]

Epsilon: What do you mean with that "but where did the new tileset go?"

He meant, when you inserted the tiles, what tiles did you replace?
---------
I know I have still yet to get a spriter, and I need more scenery... But without sprites, how'd I do?

 

[One Winged Angel]

Its too square. Put some trees so it wont be a straight line. Why would you need a spriter???? You can map the base unless your talking about new tiles.IDK.

Ill give your map a
4/10

To plain, to square, to much open space.

 

[Red Rain]

Here is my newest map, Mildawn City. This great city is home to Suchet Mansion, home to the wealthy Suchet family. It also has a port in which you can visit the snowy, Polarwind Island.

Here it is, I hope I've done well on this one. I believe it's my best yet. :D

https://img395.imageshack.us/img395/8765/mildawncitymc0.png

 

[destinedjagold]

hm.., dunno, it looks lovely to me. :)

RATING: 7/10
REASON: I like the map very much. :3 It's very nice and a bit balanced. :)
SUGGESTION: Fix the trees in the lower-left corner of the map, for they form a diagonal manner... :\

 

[Neti]

looks really cool to me, you used many self made tiles which look really good!

rating: 8/10
reason: it seems to be a very good map to me and i like your selfmade blocks and tiles
suggestions: just as destinejagold said: fix the trees in the lower elft corner and maybe do something to the path, it looks strange at some parts to me:

the parts i marked are jsut useless, you should remove them

 

[Epsilon]

Epsilon: What do you mean with that "but where did the new tileset go?"

The one that u used in topaz/garnet,
i kinda liked it :P

 

[Wichu]

Not the best, but here's my starting town:

I might make some custom tiles later.

 

[Epsilon]

Not the best, but here's my starting town:

I might make some custom tiles later.

I think it looks nice.
But are the doors supposed to look like that?

9/10
It's great!

 

[Wichu]

I forgot to mention that: the doors are events, they don't show up when I screenshot them in the editor. Here's an ingame screen:

 

[Neti]

i like the map too, but i think the palette gives the map a very sad atmosphere...
using shadow is also a ncie diea, i havent seen that before
and the shape and everything is really great, good job!
rating: 9.5/10

 

[danoftheworld]

I like the colours, and the water at the bottom it looks great!
Love all the trees..
The red and white in the flowers look out of place though?

 

[Red Rain]

About my Mildawn City, I looked through your comments, and I am very pleased with them. Thanks very much for those. I couldn't really see what you were meaning with the trees, but I did eradicate a mistake on those. I changed the cut part of the city, and decided to add a secret house there. This also gets rid of the unnecessary path before the cliff. Now, how would you rate Mildawn City now?

https://img142.imageshack.us/img142/3343/mildawncityoz4.png

 

[Neti]

looks better now, the trees in the lower left are still a bit in a straight line but its not so bad anymore
i forgot my old rating, so just add 0.5 to it, if you correct the one path i marked for you on an image (i marked two, you corrected one) you can add 1.0^^