@Naku: Care to elaborate on Abby? It seems as if you were almost sure about Abby. I didn't ask before because I thought maybe you have proof that Abby is scum and you were trying to see who sided with him and who didn't.
Exactly that. I suppose it is time to share, because at this point I doubt anyone (who is aware of Abby's identity) would risk coming to their aid now.
I can confirm that Kiyo is innocent, and that Abby is Charmander.
I'm Smeargle. I copy other people's abilities, though I can't exactly see a person's role. It's pretty simple to deduce, though.
I can confirm that Abby is a Lightkeeper. Guess what happens when Charmander's tail goes out? Sadly, this makes Charmander quite the asset to the mafia, as a Lightkeeper's death is incredibly maf-sided, so I've never seen a mafia LK before. This also means that I'm currently a Lightkeeper.
So, we can lynch Abby today, but the problem is that that would mean there would be no discussion allowed tomorrow and votes will be conducted privately via PM/Discord.
To offset this, once Abby is dead, Bard can keep the weather set to Sunny, nullifying Squirtle's votes and giving the mafia no benefit from it. The mafia also won't be able to benefit from killing me tonight, as the town will already be lights-out tomorrow thanks to Abby's death, and I'll switch off to another role during that time. Sadly I won't be getting any doctor, cop or vigilante abilities, thanks to our nice PR graveyard we have going on.
Also, Kiyo was a vanilla townie when I sketched him. Based on what we know, that makes him one of the other Eevee. As we started with 19 roles and 21 players, that means three Eevee (one for each Eeveelution, how perfect). We know Nani is Vaporeon, and with Kiyo confirmed as a second Eevee, that means there's only one Eevee left unconfirmed and able to be CCed by any mafia member, which is a benefit for us.
So, the mafia will have to contend with four confirmed townies and Castform's hindering of them. Just don't forget that Jigglypuff is potentially a cultist. I noticed that the phase post hasn't mentioned weather again, so we'll have to take Bard's word for it. If need be, we can test his claim by seeing if he can still produce sun and alter the votes in a manner that we may now track and predict.
So, for now
bandwagon this shit
and let's try to figure out a consensus on who to vote during the dark day following, otherwise the maf will get a free kill from it.