4th Gen Which starter did you choose?

[Haus of Dye]

I choose Totodile in my HeartGold. But back in my Gold version I had Cyndaquil.

 

[RandomYoshiX3]

I chose Cyndaquil because he and his Evo's are awesome=3
And i always chose the fire starter. Though i'm planning to get the grass starter in B/W

 

[Imperator161]

I picked Totodile in HG, as I always pick water types in my "main" game in each generation, and Totodile was my starter back in Gold. I chose Cyndaquil in SS because I like Typhlosion a lot, and because I used Cyndaquil in Silver. I've never been much of a Chikorita fan, I guess.

 

[Raiskit]

Cyndaquil because he's so cute and I luffle his eyes. That and his evolutions are pretty cool too.

 

[ForeverRiot]

All three. Started the game, traded each of the starter Pokémon to my girlfriend, then started up again, and then rotated between all of them. All at 100 now, natch.

 

[Pokemaster483]

I chose Cyndaquil, it's usually always the fire starter for me

 

[Blast Aftermath]

Cyndaquil, because way way way back before I had the games I had cards because that was all I was allowed parentally to have, and Typhlosion just looked amazing.

 

[Giraffe]

I restarted the other day and chose Totodile - Feraligatr is just awesome!

 

[RYOUKI]

On my first play through, I got a Cyndaquil. Boy, was he useful. He was a life saver and a lot more when he evolved into a Typhlosion(sp?).

On the next one, I thought I'd choose the Grass starter since Water types are pretty much useless for me. (Never chose a water-starter till my third playthrough in the D/P/Pt games.) But BOY, was I wrong. Chikorita was USELESS. From Falkner to Claire, Chikorita was useless, more or less. Evolved into Meganium and still no 'absorbing' moves. GAH!!

I should have chose Totodile. :'(

 

[PokéSwimmer]

Way back when I had the original Gold version, I chose Totodile. It has always been my favorite starter, so naturally I chose it for HGSS!

 

[bigplrbear]

I always go with the water type in a pokemon game, so Totodile for me

 

[The Corrupt Plague]

I went with two starters when I first got the game. I picked Cyndaquil first and as soon as I reached Violet City, I traded over a Pokemon XD Totodile with Hydrocannon that I have been saving specifically for the occasion.

 

[beedy]

yea same, totodile for me too.

 

[Version Five]

I, like always, choose the fire-type Pokemon in the games. So, yes, I chose Cyndaquil, however, I did know about the other starters you can get, so instead of getting all fires I chose to get one of each kind, Cyndaquil, Squirtle, Treeko. My favorite starters of each generation. :)

 

[Human]

Totodile. I'm usually partial to the Water type starters, and I chose the aforementioned Poke when playing both Soul Silver and Silver back in the day.

 

[Unknown#]

I actually legitly got all three! In Crystal I chose Chikorita (Also got it through a trade in SS), In Soul Silver I chose Cyndaquil and in Heart Gold I chose Totodile!

 

[xX-Nix-Xx]

I chose Cyndaquil!

I like all the starters equally (unless you add all the other regions, then Chimchar beats them all! XD)
But I just had to go for the fire type!

 

[Jonī]

I chose my Totodile. I didn't really wanna pick Chikorita and I don't like Cyndaquil because of it's popularity

 

[Kitrigar]

Totodile on HG then Cyndaquil in SS.
Restarted SS just to use Chikorita.
For some reason, I have a hard time deciding which to pick each time...

 

[Otherworld9)]

Favorite

Cyndaquil, one of my top world-wide pokemon.