SO MANY NEWIES where is everyone oldie?
Username: Varion Bluefire
Favorite Doctor: Patrick Troughton
Favorite Companion: Donna Noble
While on the topic of the Master.
I prefer the appearence of John Simm, but the motives of the first one.
I want the master to return, but none of this drumming mumbo jumbo, just plain and simple, warfare.
Welcome, another Donna lover! This is the Donna-love club. Ooh, that's the Second Doctor, right? Patrick Troughton. I'm not super well versed in the names of the old actors, I'm afraid. The Master, I didn't quite like what I've seen of the old him. He just... wanted to be mean towards the Doctor basically? I should watch more Classic Who.
Can I join this?
Nickname: Nidoking76 (or just Nido)
Favorite Doctor: David Tennant (10)
Favorite companion: Amelia Pond.
Of course you can! Welcome :3 Tennant is my favorite Doctor too. Even though all Doctors are great in their own ways, he's just the ones that comes to mind first when I think of Doctor Who (plus, he's the cutest one). Amelia Pond was great in my opinion <3 Her whole friendship with Eleven and story with Rory and River and the Doctor meeting her when she was a child and... Yeah, I think they did that really great. Was very sad to see her go.
Username: theblackvixen
Favorite Doctor: 11th
Favorite Companion: Amy Pond
While waiting for the doctor's 12th regeneration to start having adventures, I am watching 9 :) He's dark, but he's got some charm! 10 was great, but 11 is my all time favorite regeneration :)
Another Amy fan, welcome to you~ And Eleven is your favorite Doctor? Interesting. He's amazing in many ways of course, I was just annoyed with him a lot of times too. But maybe that just means he's a great character, able to make me feel so many different things. Aaa I'm really longing for Twelve's adventures with Clara to start. October is so far away... It was October right? And I'm watching Nine too actually. It's only my second watch of S1 of rebooted Who and I'm realizing that I actually loved Nine's and Rose's relationship a lot. They fit together so well somehow. If I'mma be honest, I'm not sure that Ten and Rose were quite as great together as Nine and Rose were...! But I still like Ten more for other reasons, haha.
Username: BlueWyvern4
Favorite Doctor: 10
Favorite Companion: Rose... ROSE. Bad Wolf
Welcome to the club! Rose is probably my favorite companion too. I change this opinion all the time xD But after seeing some more of her and comparing her to Clara and Amy, I've realized that Clara is a bit too good in ways, and Amy is Amy haha. Amy is awesome. But Rose was just so natural (Billie Piper <3) and fun together with the Doctor in a way no other companion quite matched. And of course there's the fact that I'm a Rose/Doctor shipper. Totally.
To bring up some kind of discussion topic...
Do you think it was the right move to completely break up with Ten's companions and stories upon his regeneration into Eleven?
Smith got whole new plot arcs and recurring characters surrounding him, and Ten really said goodbye to everyone that mattered to him at that point in his life before he regenerated between S4 and S5. This has of course got to do with the change from Russel T Davies into Steven Moffat (he regenerated!! um no). But still... I would actually have liked if they kept some kind of connection to Ten's era. Between Nine and Ten, nothing really changed. Rose and her family was still with the Doctor. And between Eleven and Twelve, I think the Pater Noster gang will still appear somehow. Or so I heard. So... such a big break between Ten and Eleven ;;