I got angry at that dude too. Considering the length of the debate by that point, the fact that he overlooked all the discussion and simply posted his rather naive opinion suggests to me that he's probably just replying to the first post of every topic he sees to bolster his post count. XD
whenever I see that on a forum, I usually reply to it very sarcastically instead of flaming people. You should try it, it's fun. :P
BTW, I noticed the theme in your profile and I love Amy Lee too. ^_^