Writer's Lounge Need advice? Want to give advice? Come on in and share ideas with your fellow writers. Just remember, all fics go in the main forum.

TrollandToad.com
Reply
 
Thread Tools
  #26    
Old November 2nd, 2007 (9:55 PM).
Enperuto's Avatar
Enperuto Enperuto is offline
Lurking Connoisseur
     
    Join Date: May 2007
    Location: Western Michigan
    Age: 24
    Gender:
    Nature: Quiet
    Posts: 72
    Quote:
    Originally Posted by -Jinx- View Post

    Think of it this way. My Tabby Cats name is not Tabby Cat and my German Shepards name is not German Shepard. Why would you call a Pikachu, Pikachu?
    Because an animal is not a pokemon. They are very different, and if there is canonical proof, i.e. that it's generally used, one would think that they would tolerate it, as they are at the very least pseudo-sentient beings.

    Another way of putting it: why would you call a elm tree Bob if everybody else called it an elm tree?
    __________________
    Whah? No signature? *vanished in poof of logic*

    Signature under construction.
    Reply With Quote

    Relevant Advertising!

      #27    
    Old November 2nd, 2007 (11:00 PM).
    Astinus's Avatar
    Astinus Astinus is offline
    Remember NovEnder
       
      Join Date: May 2006
      Location: Connecticut, USA
      Age: 30
      Gender: Male
      Posts: 10,048
      Quote:
      Originally Posted by Ranger O'Brien View Post
      Another way of putting it: why would you call a elm tree Bob if everybody else called it an elm tree?
      Because every rock and tree and creature has a life, has a spirit, has a name! *shot ninety million times*

      It is obvious that Pokemon can accept being called by generic species name. Take a look at Meowth, who seems to have a better knowledge of the human world than other Pokemon. He's perfectly fine being called "Meowth", and doesn't cry for equality.

      Ah, and Yamato-san's post reminded me of more research I need to do for another fic I'm writing.
      __________________

      The prologue begins now! Before you start to run
      Reach out with your hand and grab your freedom
      An absolute protagonist, a perfect hero...
      Sadly, these are things I'll never become

      Reply With Quote
        #28    
      Old November 3rd, 2007 (6:11 AM).
      Grovyle42(Griff8416)'s Avatar
      Grovyle42(Griff8416) Grovyle42(Griff8416) is offline
      No. 1 Grovyle Fan
      • Crystal Tier
       
      Join Date: Jun 2007
      Location: The Great Green North
      Gender: Male
      Nature: Calm
      Posts: 1,104
      I think it all comes down to the character. The Taillow in my fic (who had a name which wasn't a nickname) refused to be called a "Taillow" because he found it insulting. While other pokemon (who also have names) would rather be called by their species names.
      __________________
      [B]Claimed: Treecko, Grovyle, Charmeleon.
      Co-Owner of Treecko/Grovyle/Sceptile Club.
      Paired withAnastasia R.
      PC Family so far: Cousin - ScytheMaster, Awesomest Sister - Diamondpearl876, Brother - Rebellious Treecko (PM one of us if you want to join it)

      ------------
      Click Below for The Awesome Treecko/Grovyle/Sceptile Club
      Older Fic banner by Scenice.
      Old Fic banner by Sammi-Chan.
      New Fic banner by Scenice
      Banner and avatar by Anastasia R.
      Reply With Quote
        #29    
      Old November 8th, 2007 (5:51 PM).
      SBaby's Avatar
      SBaby SBaby is offline
      Dungeon Master
         
        Join Date: Sep 2004
        Nature: Calm
        Posts: 2,006
        More of a cliche than anything, it still remains an anomaly to this very day (as shown by posts on various sites, including here).

        The Inverse Fic/Anime Irony

        The amount of complaining you get about a Trainer Fic is inversely proportionate to how much they like the Anime. The more they like the Anime, the more they complain about an OT Fic. The reverse also applies. If they don't like the Anime, chances are you'll never hear from them, even though your view count still continues to increase.
        __________________
        If you spend too much time thinking about a thing, you will never get it done.

        - Bruce Lee

        The worst thing you can do in a business is blame the customer.

        - Willie 'Jack' Degel
        Reply With Quote
          #30    
        Old November 8th, 2007 (6:35 PM).
        Grovyle42(Griff8416)'s Avatar
        Grovyle42(Griff8416) Grovyle42(Griff8416) is offline
        No. 1 Grovyle Fan
        • Crystal Tier
         
        Join Date: Jun 2007
        Location: The Great Green North
        Gender: Male
        Nature: Calm
        Posts: 1,104
        I never noticed that, actually.
        __________________
        [B]Claimed: Treecko, Grovyle, Charmeleon.
        Co-Owner of Treecko/Grovyle/Sceptile Club.
        Paired withAnastasia R.
        PC Family so far: Cousin - ScytheMaster, Awesomest Sister - Diamondpearl876, Brother - Rebellious Treecko (PM one of us if you want to join it)

        ------------
        Click Below for The Awesome Treecko/Grovyle/Sceptile Club
        Older Fic banner by Scenice.
        Old Fic banner by Sammi-Chan.
        New Fic banner by Scenice
        Banner and avatar by Anastasia R.
        Reply With Quote
          #31    
        Old November 8th, 2007 (7:35 PM).
        Astinus's Avatar
        Astinus Astinus is offline
        Remember NovEnder
           
          Join Date: May 2006
          Location: Connecticut, USA
          Age: 30
          Gender: Male
          Posts: 10,048
          The reason behind that, I believe, is due to the fact that most OT fics follow the same plot formula of the anime. Those who have watched the anime since its beginning recognize quickly the same qualities between fic and show.

          So those who like the anime read the fics and say that the fic follows the anime too closely. Those who hate the anime read the fic and find that the fic follows the anime, and furiously hit the back button. So views increase, but reviews don't, except from those vocal enough to complain/provide concrit.

          I'm not saying that all OT fics follow the plot of the anime, even when written in the anime canon. (Mine is an example of this, though you can't see it.) It's just that the beginners who tend to give OT fics a try, and are "weak" writers, either follow the game canon too closely, or the anime canon. Since these fics are a dime a dozen, the general populace of forum goers hate OT fics. It's just another label the OT genre of Pokemon fiction has received. This stretches on to other fandoms as well.
          __________________

          The prologue begins now! Before you start to run
          Reach out with your hand and grab your freedom
          An absolute protagonist, a perfect hero...
          Sadly, these are things I'll never become

          Reply With Quote
            #32    
          Old November 8th, 2007 (8:44 PM).
          Yamato-san Yamato-san is offline
          Banned
             
            Join Date: Sep 2004
            Age: 31
            Gender:
            Nature: Adamant
            Posts: 446
            Quote:
            Originally Posted by Hanako Tabris View Post
            Ah, and Yamato-san's post reminded me of more research I need to do for another fic I'm writing.
            what was it, exactly? What I said about Japanese names, or one of the other things?
            Reply With Quote
              #33    
            Old November 9th, 2007 (1:28 PM).
            Astinus's Avatar
            Astinus Astinus is offline
            Remember NovEnder
               
              Join Date: May 2006
              Location: Connecticut, USA
              Age: 30
              Gender: Male
              Posts: 10,048
              Just the Japanese culture in general. Your post talking about the Japanese nicknames reminded me of just how little I actually know of Japanese culture. So since I am writing a fic that does take place in Japan, it all just reminded me that I had to do more research so I don't get something wrong.
              __________________

              The prologue begins now! Before you start to run
              Reach out with your hand and grab your freedom
              An absolute protagonist, a perfect hero...
              Sadly, these are things I'll never become

              Reply With Quote
                #34    
              Old November 9th, 2007 (9:23 PM).
              Duncan McNeil's Avatar
              Duncan McNeil Duncan McNeil is offline
              [release].your.grip
                 
                Join Date: Nov 2007
                Location: the depths of darkness
                Gender:
                Nature: Relaxed
                Posts: 209
                Quote:
                Originally Posted by Hanako Tabris View Post
                The reason behind that, I believe, is due to the fact that most OT fics follow the same plot formula of the anime. Those who have watched the anime since its beginning recognize quickly the same qualities between fic and show.
                You're completely right. 9 out of 10 OT fics are exactly the same, as in following the anime (and the games).

                Quote:
                Originally Posted by Hanako Tabris View Post
                I'm not saying that all OT fics follow the plot of the anime, even when written in the anime canon. (Mine is an example of this, though you can't see it.) It's just that the beginners who tend to give OT fics a try, and are "weak" writers, either follow the game canon too closely, or the anime canon. Since these fics are a dime a dozen, the general populace of forum goers hate OT fics. It's just another label the OT genre of Pokemon fiction has received. This stretches on to other fandoms as well.
                OT is probably my favorite genre of Pokemon Fan Fiction, and it's unfortunate that it has been given such a bad reputation. When done right, an OT fic can be a good fic to read and to write. When done wrong, OT fics are more "Not another one!".
                Reply With Quote
                Reply

                Quick Reply

                Join the conversation!

                Create an account to post a reply in this thread, participate in other discussions, and more!

                Create a PokéCommunity Account

                Sponsored Links
                Thread Tools

                Posting Rules
                You may not post new threads
                You may not post replies
                You may not post attachments
                You may not edit your posts

                BB code is On
                Smilies are On
                [IMG] code is On
                HTML code is Off

                Forum Jump


                All times are GMT -8. The time now is 11:04 AM.