Anti
return of the king
- 10,818
- Posts
- 16
- Years
- Kobe's Reality
- Seen Mar 6, 2022
EDIT: I'd prefer if only S&M people responded to this since they are way more familiar with what I'm trying to get at than anybody else.
I noticed that the Shoddy Battle Lounge...is dead o_O For those who don't know, it's a subforum of S&M that was put in but...nobody posts there lol.
The only two actual purposes it serves (at least as far as I know) is to allow people to have battle threads, to host tournaments, and then the NU metagame devlopment and tier threads. Let me cover these...
Battle Threads: lol useless. This isn't WiFi where your only means of communication are here on PC. You can just log onto Shoddy and ask for battles there (not like anybody actual battles on PC's server). Anybody who wants to battle can just go to the Smogon server, hit the Find Tab, and boom, you're battling.
Basically I'm saying that Shoddy itself pretty much can do what battle threads do for WiFi without the actual battle thread, so they're unneeded. The number of battle threads with literally no posts pertaining to having an actual battle is astounding. There are no battle threads that have served their purpose yet. Not one.
...So that is a huge main function of the subforum that is virtually useless. Now onto tournaments...
Tournaments: Wow, PC has a SMALL Shoddy battling population. People who are actually regulars on the Smogon and/or PC servers add up to about ten people-ish. This is a disadvantage for hosting tournaments since there aren't many possible participants. Most people who sign up mostly do "because they can" which leads to an unsuccessful tournament.
Speaking of which, I don't remember a tournament that has ever succeeded here. Ever. Yeah, the WiFi tournament in the DP section gets completed, but otherwise, I don't recall even one successful tournament. Most don't even get to the first round. Tournaments are almost never interesting since the gimmick wears off right when you realize you have to build a new team to adapt to a random new "metagame" (lol) that nobody has played.
...So that's the other huge function of the subforum that is largely useless (or hasn't worked out, at least). We don't have the competitive battling population Smogon does.
Tier Thread and NU Metagame Development thread: Both are dead, and both can be moved to S&M anyways. Truth is, S&M could probably use the activity and having a new thread or two. Besides, we basically use Smogon's tier list totally (unless we all-of-a-sudden aren't doing the UU/BL merger?) and the NU Metagame Development Thread...nobody cares about it anymore, to be frank. Besides, UU is changing a lot right now, so it's kind of not really a good time for that discussion to take place.
--------------
So I'm essentially saying that battle threads are beyond useless and tournaments never actually are successful/fun, and that's pretty much what the forum is for.
I think that either the subforum should be downright removed, or the focus should be significantly altered. It's just dead right now and is withering away faster than the economy X]
What are your thoughts on this?
I noticed that the Shoddy Battle Lounge...is dead o_O For those who don't know, it's a subforum of S&M that was put in but...nobody posts there lol.
The only two actual purposes it serves (at least as far as I know) is to allow people to have battle threads, to host tournaments, and then the NU metagame devlopment and tier threads. Let me cover these...
Battle Threads: lol useless. This isn't WiFi where your only means of communication are here on PC. You can just log onto Shoddy and ask for battles there (not like anybody actual battles on PC's server). Anybody who wants to battle can just go to the Smogon server, hit the Find Tab, and boom, you're battling.
Basically I'm saying that Shoddy itself pretty much can do what battle threads do for WiFi without the actual battle thread, so they're unneeded. The number of battle threads with literally no posts pertaining to having an actual battle is astounding. There are no battle threads that have served their purpose yet. Not one.
...So that is a huge main function of the subforum that is virtually useless. Now onto tournaments...
Tournaments: Wow, PC has a SMALL Shoddy battling population. People who are actually regulars on the Smogon and/or PC servers add up to about ten people-ish. This is a disadvantage for hosting tournaments since there aren't many possible participants. Most people who sign up mostly do "because they can" which leads to an unsuccessful tournament.
Speaking of which, I don't remember a tournament that has ever succeeded here. Ever. Yeah, the WiFi tournament in the DP section gets completed, but otherwise, I don't recall even one successful tournament. Most don't even get to the first round. Tournaments are almost never interesting since the gimmick wears off right when you realize you have to build a new team to adapt to a random new "metagame" (lol) that nobody has played.
...So that's the other huge function of the subforum that is largely useless (or hasn't worked out, at least). We don't have the competitive battling population Smogon does.
Tier Thread and NU Metagame Development thread: Both are dead, and both can be moved to S&M anyways. Truth is, S&M could probably use the activity and having a new thread or two. Besides, we basically use Smogon's tier list totally (unless we all-of-a-sudden aren't doing the UU/BL merger?) and the NU Metagame Development Thread...nobody cares about it anymore, to be frank. Besides, UU is changing a lot right now, so it's kind of not really a good time for that discussion to take place.
--------------
So I'm essentially saying that battle threads are beyond useless and tournaments never actually are successful/fun, and that's pretty much what the forum is for.
I think that either the subforum should be downright removed, or the focus should be significantly altered. It's just dead right now and is withering away faster than the economy X]
What are your thoughts on this?
Last edited: