Map Rating Thread

p!kablu said:

Name: Everwood Bay (starting town)
Game: Pokemon Twilight (subject to change)
Other Comments: I recolored some palettes of the FRLG template. I'm not sure how to take the grid lines off but anyway, I like how it turned out.
Map:

Click to expand...

5.4\10
Why?: There are a couple of things that annoy me about this map.
One of them is the little, 1 tile walking spaces.
They cut off playabillity and can sometimes frustrate the player.
Another thing is the completly staight mountains.
Mountains should be wavy, not completely straight.
And those rocks in the sea should have deep water around them, they don't normally stand alone.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------

Map Name: Gradia Village
Map Editor: RPGXP
Game: Pokemon Periodot
Other Comments: None

Map shot:

Name: Cielo town
Game: Pokemon White Light
Other Comments: Ok so this is the starting town in the game tiles are by me kyledove saurav alisatair and rhevarhe_duh
Map:

f0r3v3r-70x1c said:

heres a nice little map you yall today it started off as just a test for the forest shadow system but ended up turning into a serious map :D this one wont be in the game its way to small

Click to expand...

I love that. I kinda want to steal your forest shadow fog... *pouts*

sorry to sound like a noob, but how do i fit my whole map into one picture?

Florio said:

sorry to sound like a noob, but how do i fit my whole map into one picture?

Click to expand...

it depends what program you are using

Map Name- Snowden Town
Comments- This will be the starter town for a game I'm working on called Blizzard White,

f0r3v3r-70x1c said:

it depends what program you are using

Click to expand...

im using rmxp, pokemon essentials

Florio said:

im using rmxp, pokemon essentials

Click to expand...

:D i didnt mean that i could help you sorry i dont use rmxp or any other game making programs im making mine on flash

I might use some of these in my game. I'll pm someone if I do.

Randydrew66 said:

I might use some of these in my game. I'll pm someone if I do.

Click to expand...

I wouldn't use any of the maps if I were you, none of them are for anyone else to use. All of these maps are from the individuals own games. Not for you, or anyone else to use.

Randydrew66 said:

I might use some of these in my game. I'll pm someone if I do.

Click to expand...

dont even think about it make your own maps dont steal other peoples

It seems that no one is rating on the maps anymore...

f0r3v3r-70x1c said:

Name: Cielo town
Game: Pokemon White Light
Other Comments: Ok so this is the starting town in the game tiles are by me kyledove saurav alisatair and rhevarhe_duh
Map:

Click to expand...

ok so i wish theywould rate this map i worked hard on this bad boy

f0r3v3r-70x1c said:

ok so i wish theywould rate this map i worked hard on this bad boy

Click to expand...

It looked a bit isolated from civilization/ abandoned. Love the greens... 7.5/10

Where did you get the tiles from? They look like Waudby's, ones which he didn't release to the public...

riceeman said:

Where did you get the tiles from? They look like Waudby's, ones which he didn't release to the public...

Click to expand...

nope there a combination of mine saurav's alistairs rhevarha_duh's and kyle's

i would never use anyones tiles without permision i asked Waudby if i could use his mountains a few weeks ago and he said no so i accepted it

f0r3v3r-70x1c said:

ok so i wish theywould rate this map i worked hard on this bad boy

Click to expand...

It's nice, but over-all it feels very cluttered and busy.

f0r3v3r-70x1c said:

nope there a combination of mine saurav's alistairs rhevarha_duh's and kyle's

i would never use anyones tiles without permision i asked Waudby if i could use his mountains a few weeks ago and he said no so i accepted it

Click to expand...

Oh sorry, my mistake *sweat drop* I have to agree with everyone else - The map is nice, but is somehow spread out and too cluttered at the same time - I like it though, because I like more realistic maps.

261Poochyena said:

Map Name- Snowden Town
Comments- This will be the starter town for a game I'm working on called Blizzard White,

Click to expand...

I wish someone would rate this, my friend worked hard with this! She didn't even use advanced map to make it. I love it.