Suggestion: B/W Forum Challenge

[Porygon Z]

Not really a Challenge like the addicted forum, but some little challenges open for all PC users, like catching a Mild nature Patrat, and so on.

What do you think about it?

 

[Sydian]

That sounds kind of boring tbh. Not much of a challenge anyway, like with what's in the Challenge forum.

 

[Captain Fabio]

I agree with Syd.
It doesn't sound great to be honest. The challenges are meant to be challenging.

But speak to Forever if you like.​

​

 

[Alternative]

To me, it doesn't really seem like the sort of challenge which belongs in the Black and White forum. Seems more like a Trade Corner challenge if you ask me, but I think it would be better if it was more technical, like breed an Archen with a Mild Nature and x/31/x/31/x/31 IVs or something. :/ Just ask Forever or TwilightBlade about it.

 

[Ho-Oh]

So it is about the B/W section...?
I'll respond then, since people seem to be directing the user to me in here.

I wouldn't allow it in the B/W section because all challenges belong in the challenges section anyway. :x Except if we have specific events, but that doesn't really sound like something that would suit the B/W specific events.

And even so, a "what natures are your Pokemon" thread in general wouldn't fit in B/W. Just make it a little more complicated and post it in challenges imo from what Syd said.

 

[Sydian]

If you plan on making that into a challenge, I'd get some more ideas in the CI&D...because I can't really see that becoming a challenge. Most of us really look down on challenges that revolve around natures anyway. If you notice, there are absolutely no challenges based off them. It's like stories told in second person POV in a way. Unless they're really good, you just won't be seeing them around.

 

[TwilightBlade]

I never really liked classic challenges because participants have to restart their game, right? I would like to see some Breeder's Challenges... That would attract a different crowd + offer post-game missions/tasks for the bored crowd.

However, Everstone+Ditto makes breeding natures easy. Synchonizers are the same. IV Breeding is a little complicated so that can prove to be challenging for some.

I don't know if you originally intended for a Breeder's Challenge... But if so, maybe my crew has something in the works.