Banners

[Nine]

Just a couple of banners I've made over the past couple of weeks... Comments and criticisms greatly appreciated.

One
Two
Three
Four
Five
Six
Seven
Eight

Some are unfinished, and yes I use the same renders/stocks alot... Oh well. :D!

 

[Team Magma Girl]

WOW! Those are really good. 100/10. ^_^

 

[PrinceOfDarkness]

Nine, those are the most awesome banners I have seen. Like the coolest(in my opinion ppl) 1000000000/10.....or is that too much XD

 

[Sawyer]

the brushing and rendering is very fine, but i'd suggest making a more noticeable border. i suppose i'll rate it this way to fit with the rest of the crowd. 8.9/10 (yes, i know, i'm a tough crit, but i'm a veteran gfx designer)

 

[Nine]

the brushing and rendering is very fine, but i'd suggest making a more noticeable border. i suppose i'll rate it this way to fit with the rest of the crowd. 8.9/10 (yes, i know, i'm a tough crit, but i'm a veteran gfx designer)

I figured as much, I was hoping you'd respond.

Yeah I know I need to work on the borders but hell, I'm lazy. :P

 

[PrinceOfDarkness]

ur not lazy, hell, those are waaay toooo cool. I can't stop but stare at them. *stares at them for alooooong time*

 

[Composer of Requiems]

7,8 are very fine. The others... the first few are very nice, but to be honest, I feel that you shouldn't be putting almost identical sigs together unless you want them to be compared. Give it about... a week between each one? By then most people forget what the previous week's one is like.

 

[Team Magma Girl]

My favorite is the first one. I think its really pretty. Great work Nine

 

[PrinceOfDarkness]

My favorite is the first one. I think its really pretty. Great work Nine

Hey, that's the one I like. which is also in her sig. Good job, and keep up the good work. ;) :)

 

[Nine]

7,8 are very fine. The others... the first few are very nice, but to be honest, I feel that you shouldn't be putting almost identical sigs together unless you want them to be compared. Give it about... a week between each one? By then most people forget what the previous week's one is like.

Seven and eight took me bloody ages... Just seems easier to not take forever on them, idk, I get mad at them... XD

Thanks for the honest crit btw.

 

[Sawyer]

well, if you use Photoshop, it takes about a minute to add a border, if you mean a basic i px border. in mine, i always stroke it, but sometimes make edges, etc. transparent.

 

[Nine]

Yeah, most of them do have a 1 px white border but you can't see it... x_x

Although some WIP don't, and some earlier ones don't. I try to always add a border though.

 

[MystiKal]

Hmm I like 8 but you need to work on your text then your sigs would be great.

 

[Sawyer]

yeah... with a celestial banner, i suggest a bigger font, possibly cursive. as long as it's noticeable ^^

 

[Pincushion]

There really good..you should start a request *rolls eyes*

 

[Nine]

There really good..you should start a request *rolls eyes*

If anyone wants one they can PM/IM me.