Christmas Pokemon Fanfiction Contest

lol... and you're comparing me this little 15 year old who has to drop out of English IB and into English regular because his english sucks so bad, to a professional english professor? It's a mismatch before the comparison is even made? ;p

And it's hard to believe that you're the same DP at times... compare to the one a few weeks ago who's lamenting with a lack of self confidence of her own writing skills. ;p
 
LilyPichu said:
Even if Dragonfree has already remarked upon, this, I must.

For one thing, you're criticizing one of the best reviewers and friend I have ever seen? Why? Just because of the fact he knows how to give a good review? Rather ironic, don't ya think? Think it over. I don't mind if he gives contructive criticism. Mind you, if it were to be flaming, then I would understand but this...is just pointless in my opinion.

So Denny, you would rather get a '10/10 OMG this is like, so good keep it up!' rather than helpful advice many people have perceived in the mean category? Just admit you're that afraid of getting reviews from him, instead of marking him as a 'cold' reviewer as well as disrespectful. Trust me sweetie, you haven't seen disrespectful yet.

So yeah, bear that in mind. But by all means, if you don't want to enter this contest just because an experienced reviewer is taking part into being judge, then be my guest.

^_^


~LP

He's just intense! I'll give you that! He'll make anyone down in the dumps, no offense. I'm just a little upset with:

a) A REALLY lengthy review.
b) A REALLY pessimistic one to let me down.
c) Suggests that I "Try again".

I get pessimistic reviews, but this: Unbelivable! It's the mother of all hatred!

Hey, Frosty, why don't you see how it all began? Go to the TPT, look for me {Same alias}, then click This is the End. 'Tis a story on how I started writing my three fanfics, but, stopped abruptly.

Now, Frosty, do you understand? No? Oh well, just don't review any of my stories anymore.
 
...Dare I intrude? :P

[thinking]

It has been quite a while since last I attempted to write a short story or a poem, but I feel that a knowledgeable judge is much better than some googly-eyed wannabe critic who dishes out positive commentary on the basis of a story's cuteness and his/her familiarity with the author rather than the work's structure, originality, and depth. One must understand the rules of a contest before entering, and the basis by which one's entry will be judged. The proper usage of the English language should not be regarded as an obstacle; it is the unseen scaffolding that supports a great story, and the vehicle by which you reach the reader's heart.

[/thinking]
 
Pok?mon Master Denny said:
He's just intense! I'll give you that! He'll make anyone down in the dumps, no offense. I'm just a little upset with:

a) A REALLY lengthy review.
b) A REALLY pessimistic one to let me down.
c) Suggests that I "Try again".

I get pessimistic reviews, but this: Unbelivable! It's the mother of all hatred!

Hey, Frosty, why don't you see how it all began? Go to the TPT, look for me {Same alias}, then click This is the End. 'Tis a story on how I started writing my three fanfics, but, stopped abruptly.

Now, Frosty, do you understand? No? Oh well, just don't review any of my stories anymore.

Then try again. You can't master something unless you fail a hundred thousand times. No author (except prodigies) ever got a status without failing dozens of times, you know...
 
Uh, Denny, you sound a bit of a sore loser if you don't mind me saying. All good authors - and bad authors, and those in-between and exceptionally good/bad - end up with one stinging review at least. It's not just a fan fiction matter.

It happens to real life authors all the time. (Don't believe me? PM me. I've recieved plenty o' good reviews and a few ouch-y ones.)

A lengthy review is good. It goes into more detail, and makes sure you understand how (if it's a good lengthy review) to fix up your problems or errors.

Frostweaver is the kind of reviewer I would kill for to even glance at my prologue.

And that's saying something.

Also, "Try again" is constructive. This is mean: "Scrap it, it's terrible. Forget it."

It's encouragement to fix up your errors.

Also, "This is the end" is basically just a sulking rant from how you describe it. I couldn't be bothered reading you whinging because you're annoyed because some people aren't gushy "OMG YOU'RE SO GOOD AT WRITING!" (no offense to my lovely reviewers), but actually pick out errors to help you.

Also, hmph. Don't want help? Fine. I won't stick up for those who don't want to be stuck up for. (not you Denny. Frostweaver.)

I'm not old enough for uni. My teacher is specially trained in high-IQ training, yes, but she isn't an English professor.

And Oni, yeah, even me, who people have described as (OMG) amazing and prolific, have had bazillions of failures.

There are times I want to throw my contract in the bin. (and all my works of fiction. It ain't as easy as it looks to stand through editing.)

For example, my publisher and I had email communication (interstate) and what I was really proud of got edited so many times and picked at so many times I wanted to send a cutting email back "Edit it yourself." only she was really nice it was just frazzling because we went through so many editing processes.

And, no, "lamenting at lack of writing skills"? I didn't mention my laments and writing skills. I used myself, a real-life author, as an example to say something.

I'm the same old DP with a bit of heart in me. I wasn't happy with my writing (laws, if it was any good I might actually smile for a change), I was sticking up for someone I admired.

Don't want help?

Fine with me.

I don't believe in wasting of effort.

Oh, and by the way, I have had a really bad day. Cried twice. Had a couple of feuds. Took a few personal insults. (Debating ain't that healthy for emotional people like me. Even when the opponents cheer ya for a good speech, it still ain't healthy.)

Oh, today's a new day, and I've made up my mind not to enter.

Right now, I don't even feel like writing fan fiction ever again, OK?

*puts on mocking, high-pitched voice* OK, sure, Dark_Pikachu, you're so bad at everything you do, that's why you're bullied by everyone for trying to help!*

*puts on normal voice* Precisely, myself. This world's morals are severely unbalanced. Why, a person is attacked for offering to help! My, my, what is this world - forum - coming to?

That I don't know, but somehow Serebii's high-traffic-jam fan fiction forum has more appeal now...

CHANGE OF PLAN! ME IS STAYING RIGHT HERE! whoopee positivity ooh yeah positivity (I sound like a hippie XD)

~DP
 
Last edited:
-Another format is added, which I forgot in the past... "Diary Fanfic"

(hmm... should a mod sticky this and turn this into an "official" contest?)
 
Good idea, I'm sure oni will approve...at least, until Christmas, right? XP

*stickeh*
 
I'm... stumped.

And one month to go!!! :(

Can anyone give me advice? *rubs head because it hurts*

It's the idea part that's the hardest...
 
Um... I usually like to help, but not this time since I'm a judge myself ^^; And technically you have more than 1 month... it's just the 3rd today and it's not going to be "due" until Dec 20th ^^
 
Um... a month and 16 days :)

um... er... this might need some Christmas research... um... er.......................

but I won't give... um... up!

thanks for kinda offering (like ya said ya would but you are a judge so yeah)

No Santa... NO SANTA... must not use santa... ugh.

Wish I was like Lily, who can have ideas and write ;) Oh well... I do have ideas... just not brilliant ideas... all i know is i need snow in it... I have this desire to write a cold snowy Xmas... I. am. sick. of. hot. Christmases. I mean it is hot over here... oh well frosty has extremely cold xmases he probably wouldn't mind swapping... only I can't swap.
 
Actually, hot Christmas' are surprisingly original and turn out into something new, considering majority knows the holiday as snow and ice. <I don't think some even celebrate it...> So you might want to approach that thought. XP
 
Good point... well I started writing a fic and it turned out to have nothing to do with Christmas...

OMG OMG OMG OMG LILY YOU HAVE INSPIRED ME! I now know how to tie it in with Christmas!!! Thank you!
 
Christmas Fanfiction Contest is just 27 days away!

Hope that everyone is preparing themselves now? ;p
As for new writers who are interested to join this, now is not too late just yet, so start writing!
 
Hmm...

You know, I'm actually intersted in joining if I could, but there's a teensy problem - my mid-terms are on the 20th and 21st (as well as the 16th and 17th.) I don't know if I could submit my fanfic on time...

I've got a great idea that could be turn into (an) episode(s) if the producers wanted to in my opinion. (sorry, it involves snow and ice) Although I'm a first time fan-fic writer, I don't mind massive criticism from judges. (surviving 3 1/2 years in high school in AP/honors english, I've learn to either pay heed to them, or just ignore them completely because I just don't like the teacher)
 
Wow, I didn't see this until now. When you say it has to tie in with Christmas theme, does there has to be some mention of Christmas? Or can you just use allusion and symbolism?

It's not too late to join, right? Right? :D
 
Of course it's not too late~

If you're confused about the topic, read the first post. I believe it tells you...o.o
 
dqle said:
Hmm...

You know, I'm actually intersted in joining if I could, but there's a teensy problem - my mid-terms are on the 20th and 21st (as well as the 16th and 17th.) I don't know if I could submit my fanfic on time...

I've got a great idea that could be turn into (an) episode(s) if the producers wanted to in my opinion. (sorry, it involves snow and ice) Although I'm a first time fan-fic writer, I don't mind massive criticism from judges. (surviving 3 1/2 years in high school in AP/honors english, I've learn to either pay heed to them, or just ignore them completely because I just don't like the teacher)
lol... I know IB does the same pretty much ^^;

Yes feel free to submit it later if you need to be, but I just know PC kinda well and know that I always have to set a date earlier than my plans XD; But it's just that you may get a result later than the others or so. ^^; Just try to give it to me asap and it'll be fine.
 
All right. Thanks a lot for telling me. I just hope it isn't too long. (I have yet to organize it)
 
LilyPichu said:
If you're confused about the topic, read the first post. I believe it tells you...o.o

All right. I'm sorry. Here's what I've noticed from frostweaver's initial post.

frostweaver said:
...related to Christmas...

-keep in mind that Christmas does NOT equate to just any cold winter days... just look at Australia and check how "cold" is Australia when they're celebrating Christmas... >_>;

The fanfic has to be related to christmas, or any practices that are done near Christmas time. Please use common sense regarding "what is Christmas." >>;

-christmas isn't necessarily all jolly... it doesn't *have* to be.

From this I gather: 'related to Christmas' 'NOT just cold winter days' 'practices done near Christmas' and 'common sense'. Unfortunately, I have very little of the latter. x.x

Maybe I can just interpreted that as 'directly or indirectly to Christmas but NOT simply winter season or general festivities'. If so, I would like to ask frostweaver: can I allude to Christmas multiple times and through the course of the story, but without making any mention of Christmas itself? I think it'd be interesting to reference Christmas in phrasing, word choice, and abstract/vaguely mentioned symbols--for instance, people exchanging gifts that they don't realize are gifts until the very end (because they're not physical gifts), the birth of a person or Pokemon in a humble environment, or simply color-coded Pokemon. Know what I'm saying?

Thanks.
 
doesn't have to take place at christmas or even have to mention christmas, if your theme is christmas-related or is the reverse of christmas (who said that having the reversed ideas of christmas isn't related to christmas?). But be sure to definitely keep in *close touch* with that as theme, not just a mere allusion.

In other words, as long as the theme contains idea of about christmas (or an explanation of a world lacking in christmas ideas), it's fine.
 
Back
Top